SCENE FEED

105 Comments

Graduation

4 days ago

Girls can play football after all, archbishop says

By MICHAEL OVERALL Staff Writer on Mar 18, 2013, at 11:46 AM  Updated on 3/18 at 11:46 AM



BECAUSE I SAID SO

From Ohio, hope for parents of missing children everywhere

Amanda Berry went missing 10 years ago after leaving work at Burger King.

Michelle Knight was apparently thought to ...

Comp time vs. overtime: Employees should have the right to choose

When I started school in the mid-1970s, nearly two out of three mothers still stayed home with their kids.

But now it’s ...

OKC and Boston: Too close and too soon

On a trip to Oklahoma City last weekend, my 4-year-old saw the bombing memorial for the first time, describing the empty ...

CONTACT THE BLOGGER

Michael Overall

918-581-8383
Email

2013/3/AX122_1237_9.JPG

Caroline Pla reportedly plays on both the offensive and defensive lines, so I'm not sure why she's carrying the ball in this photo from 2012. Maybe she recovered a fumble?


Facing a controversy over an 11-year-old girl who wanted to play football for a Catholic school, the archbishop of Philadelphia asked a committee to study the issue.

And last week those committee members -- including coaches, pastors and medical experts -- voted "by a wide margin" to keep girls out of the league, according to press reports.

Caroline Pla spent two seasons playing as both an offensive and defensive lineman in the Catholic Youth Organization. And by all accounts, she was good at it.

But the rule book said "boys only." And after an opposing team made an issue of it, the league had no choice but to enforce its own regulation.

Caroline was banned. But her parents took their case to the media. And thousands of people signed a petition to have the rules changed, saying it wasn't fair to keep Caroline off the field.

The archbishop's committee, however, had to ask if it was fair to the boys to make them play against her.

Football is a full contact sport. And even through the padding, pubescent boys are sure to notice a few differences.

And those boys might not particularly want to be manhandled by her either. It could be, as Catholics would say, an "occasion of sin."

But Archbishop Charles Chaput overruled his committee and lifted the ban on girl football players.

He's more devout and prayerful than I am, so I won't second guess him. But the priests of Philadelphia might be hearing some unusual confessions from junior-varsity sixth-graders.

Read more details HERE.





BECAUSE I SAID SO

From Ohio, hope for parents of missing children everywhere

Amanda Berry went missing 10 years ago after leaving work at Burger King.

Michelle Knight was apparently thought to ...

Comp time vs. overtime: Employees should have the right to choose

When I started school in the mid-1970s, nearly two out of three mothers still stayed home with their kids.

But now it’s ...

OKC and Boston: Too close and too soon

On a trip to Oklahoma City last weekend, my 4-year-old saw the bombing memorial for the first time, describing the empty ...

CONTACT THE BLOGGER

Michael Overall

918-581-8383
Email

COMMENTS

Only active print or digital subscribers of the Tulsa World are allowed to post comments on stories posted to Tulsaworld.com. After you fill out the form below and click submit, your comment will be published instantly online along with your screen name.

By clicking "Submit" you are agreeing to our terms and conditions.

SCENE FEED

105 Comments

Graduation

4 days ago