SCENE FEED

105 Comments

Graduation

2 days ago

Oscar for Best Picture: 'Lincoln' or 'Argo?'

By MICHAEL SMITH Movie Critic on Jan 28, 2013, at 12:03 PM  Updated on 1/28 at 1:21 PM



I SEE MOVIES FOR FREE

"The Outsiders"/"Rumble Fish" drive-in double-feature Thursday

A pair of Tulsa icons come together Thursday night as 'The Outsiders' kicks off a special double-feature event at the Admiral ...

"History of the Eagles" DVD: Classic-rock heaven

There's a reason that the Eagles were the opening-night act for both Tulsa's BOK Center and the Ford Center in Oklahoma City: ...

Tim Blake Nelson's new movie with James Franco at Cannes

'As I Lay Dying,' a film based on the William Faulkner novel and featuring James Franco and Tulsa native Tim Blake Nelson, ...

CONTACT THE BLOGGER

Michael Smith

918-581-8479
Email

2013/1/argoposter.jpg

"Argo"


2013/1/DDL.JPG

"Lincoln"


Three weeks ago, when the Academy Awards nominations were announced, I made my case: "Lincoln" would win the Oscar as best picture.

It was a well-reasoned decision based on many factors. Key among them was the snub of "Argo's" Ben Affleck in the best director category. Only three times in 84 years has the best picture Oscar gone to a movie with no director nomination.

Three weeks later and a couple of key award wins, the momentum in the best-picture race may have shifted to "Argo," Affleck's exceptionally entertaining political drama based on a true story about rescuing Americans during the Iran hostage crisis.

When Affleck was snubbed, people in Hollywood were baffled. Every other group handing out awards seemed to think that Affleck was a deserving nominee, if not a winner, except for the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.

It may be that people in Hollywood were also ticked off, and Hollywood loves a good revenge story.

The snub may be what has energized the awards race for "Argo," which over the weekend won two key awards that have historically served as precursors for the Oscars.

On Saturday, "Argo" bested the competition in the Producers Guild Awards, which uses a system similar to that of the Oscar to pick a winner. On Sunday, "Argo" won the best cast award at the Screen Actors Guild, which is that organization's equivalent of a best-picture win.

"Lincoln" finished as an also-ran in both award contests, but there's still reason to believe that Steven Spielberg's picture will win the top Oscar on Feb. 24. I can't rule out the embarrassment factor.

Without question, the Academy has egg on its face for Affleck having not been nominated in the director race. That will only heighten if "Argo" wins best picture without that nomination, which hasn't happened since 1989, when "Driving Miss Daisy" won best picture without Bruce Beresford being nominated as best director.

Watch for the results of this Saturday's Directors Guild Award, when Spielberg and Affleck are both nominated. An Affleck win would make "Argo" a solid front-runner; a Spielberg win would muddle the picture.

If my prediction of a "Lincoln" win for best picture at the Oscars ends up incorrect and "Argo" takes home the top prize, I would be thrilled to be wrong.

In my Dec. 28 top-10 list published in the Tulsa World, I named "Argo" the No. 1 movie of 2012. "Lincoln" finished in my "second 10" list at No. 12.
I SEE MOVIES FOR FREE

"The Outsiders"/"Rumble Fish" drive-in double-feature Thursday

A pair of Tulsa icons come together Thursday night as 'The Outsiders' kicks off a special double-feature event at the Admiral ...

"History of the Eagles" DVD: Classic-rock heaven

There's a reason that the Eagles were the opening-night act for both Tulsa's BOK Center and the Ford Center in Oklahoma City: ...

Tim Blake Nelson's new movie with James Franco at Cannes

'As I Lay Dying,' a film based on the William Faulkner novel and featuring James Franco and Tulsa native Tim Blake Nelson, ...

CONTACT THE BLOGGER

Michael Smith

918-581-8479
Email

COMMENTS

Only active print or digital subscribers of the Tulsa World are allowed to post comments on stories posted to Tulsaworld.com. After you fill out the form below and click submit, your comment will be published instantly online along with your screen name.

By clicking "Submit" you are agreeing to our terms and conditions.

SCENE FEED

105 Comments

Graduation

2 days ago