READ TODAY'S STORIES AND E-EDITION
SUBSCRIBE
|
CONTACT US
|
SIGN IN
news
sports
business
scene
opinion
obits
blogs
comics
multimedia
weather
jobs
autos
homes
pets
classifieds
search
OU
|
OSU
|
TU
|
ORU
|
HIGH SCHOOLS
|
THUNDER
|
COLLEGE FOOTBALL
|
COLLEGE BASKETBALL
|
NFL
|
OUTDOORS
|
GOLF
|
PROS
|
ALL
@TWSportsExtra
HOMEPAGES
OU Sooners
OSU Cowboys
TU Golden Hurricane
ORU Golden Eagles
High School Sports
College Football
2012 High School Football Preview
2012 College Football Preview
SPORTS EXTRA BLOGS
OKC Thunder
OU Sooners
OSU Cowboys
TU Golden Hurricane
ORU Golden Eagles
High School Sports
Sports Writer Jimmie Tramel
Outdoors Writer Kelly Bostian
Fantasy Football
Pro Baseball
FOR THE RECORD
Scores, statistics and standings for local and national sports.
LOCAL PROS
Tulsa 66ers
Tulsa Drillers
Tulsa Oilers
Tulsa Shock
Tulsa Talons
Oklahoma City Thunder
ALL SPORTS
Golf
Horse racing
Major League Baseball
Motorsports
NBA
NFL
NHL
Other sports
PHOTOS & VIDEOS
OU photo slide shows
OSU photo slide shows
TU photo slide shows
College football highlights
OUTDOORS
Home page
Kelly Bostian's columns
Kelly Bostian's blogs
Videos
Slide shows
FIND A STORY
Search the World's archives
EMAIL ALERTS
OU Sooners
OSU Cowboys
TU Golden Hurricane
High Schools
SOCIAL MEDIA
Sports Extra on Facebook
@TWSportsExtra
@MGPeters23
@EricBaileyTW
@MikeBrownTW
@GuerinEmig
@BillHaisten
@KellyHinesTW
@JohnEHoover
@JohnKleinTW
@BarryLewisTW
@JimmieTramel
@ThePicker
@kellybostian
@TWfantasyworld
RSS FEEDS
OU Sooners
OSU Cowboys
TU Golden Hurricane
ORU Golden Eagles
High School Football
John Klein Columns
Picker columns
CONTACT US
Editors
Michael Peters
Sports Editor
Patrick Prince
Asst. Sports Editor
Columnists
John Klein
Sr. Columnist
John E. Hoover
Columnist
Writers
Eric Bailey
OU sports, Big 12 sports
Guerin Emig
OU sports
Jimmie Tramel
OSU sports, ORU sports
Kelly Hines
OSU sports
Bill Haisten
TU sports, Thunder
Barry Lewis
High Schools, Drillers
Mike Brown
High Schools, Shock
Kelly Bostian
Outdoors
BUY PHOTOS & PAGES
Buy a published photo by clicking the "Order this Picture" link on the photo. For a full-color page reprint, call 732-8198 from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday-Friday or
order online
.
ADVERTISE ON SPORTS EXTRA
Learn more about the site.
Your bookmark will appear on your Profile page. Please give it a title,
and short description so that visitors to your page will understand where
the bookmark leads.
Bookmark Title :
Bookmark Text :
OSU Field Goal Against Iowa State was Probably Good
Published:
1/12/2012 5:19 PM
Last Modified:
1/12/2012 5:19 PM
Regarding the controversy that kept OSU out of the national championship game: the field goal that could have been good but was ruled bad.
The rule is supposed to be: If it goes over the post, it's no good.
That makes no sense.
If you extended the goal posts up to infinity, a ball hitting a poll dead center could bounce out. Or in. There are laces on the football. Laces hitting posts cause funny bounces. Spin on a ball causes funny bounces. So there's no certainty a ball going over the posts would have bounced out.
Put some lasers on the posts, the kick is good or bad, period. Lasers can tell if tennis serves hit 130 miles per hour are good or bad in a second. Also, put a laser on the goal line. Just like the finish line at a horse race. It's a touchdown or not, find out in five seconds.
The field goal rule is old and dumb.
OSU probably got robbed.
Reader Comments
11 Total
Show:
Newest First
Learn About Our Comment Policy
Dee-Bo
(last year)
The other way they could have won is to take it out of the referees hands. They were off that night and lost. The better team lost.
JG78
(last year)
So, lets make more excuses for OSU. According to your logic, Mike Gundy is 0-1 in big games this year. Since the ISU game against a 6-6 opponent kept OSU from playing for a National Championship.
The Truth Hurts
(last year)
Is Robert Allen ghostwriting for the Picker? Yeah, lets change the rules because OSU choked against a 27 point 'dog. By your Big Game Bob logic, the Fiesta Bowl win was not a big game...the ISU game was big, becuase they lost. Turnabout fair play right?
MexiMike
(last year)
I thought it actually was closer to being inside the uprights than dead even on top of them. I really never understood why they don't just extend the uprights higher.
Even worse, why isn't that play even reviewable? You have cameras catching the flight at different angles. It's a dead ball after the play one way or the other. It seems dumb to be able to review one form of scoring but not another.
With all that said, it is what it is. OSU lost but went on to win their first BCS bowl. I'd rather celebrate the positive than dwell on the negative.
Ferris Bueller
(last year)
Brilliant idea.
Barney Doyle
(last year)
See. The Pickers picks don't matter as long as his columns are always dead on.
justafan
(last year)
You had me until you talked about the laser on the goal line. Always nice to start the day with a laugh. Good one.
sokodad
(last year)
It feels good to be the Champs. So proud of the Pokes.
John Nash
(last year)
Stale stuff here.
C'mon Picker, we're in the middle of the NFL Playoffs, Oilers are doing pretty good, so are the Thunder(or is that out of your jurisdiction?). Put some effort into it, son...there's got to be something better to blog about than picking this old scab.
redriverndn
(last year)
The Pick has already written off the NBA season as boring & uneventful, Miami beats the Thunder in 6 is his astute determination & that no one needs to watch a game until the last few minutes....
I was informed that the Pick isn't a sole entity & that this column is a conglomeration of TW sportswriters & to me, that's so very sad that they view a PROFESSIONAL basketball league unworthy of TW print space.... But I'm not suprised as this column does it's best to trample on the WNBA team that Tulsa has....
This column loves to write about so-called amateur sports, Sooners, Pokes, TU & ORU & I guess going outside the boundries of amateur sports & into the world of professional athletics ais a frightening pilgrimage that would expose the TW writers as the local yahoos that they really are....
I find that sad because their lack of vision ensures that their readers are as uninformed as they are....
The Picker
(last year)
Redriver, we love pro basketball, starting with the Thunder. We were the first to discover Perkins couldn't score a lick. It is the number one story in the state at the moment. With regard to the WNBA, it's a different game and takes times to get used to it. They use a smaller basketball and the same rim. It's hard to love a team that loses all the time. If it gets better, attendance will improve, and so will coverage.
11 comments displayed
To post comments on tulsaworld.com, you must be an active Tulsa World print or digital subscriber and signed into your account.
To sign in to your account, go to
tulsaworld.com/signin
.
To activate your print subscription for unlimited digital access and to post comments, go to
tulsaworld.com/activate
.
To purchase a subscription, go to
tulsaworld.com/subscribe
.
Submitting your comment, please wait...
Out Pick The Picker
The Picker began entertaining – and infuriating – sports fans in 1993. Each week during football season, he writes about his picks of college and NFL games in his Thursday Sports column. He's never afraid of sharing his opinions about the game and the personalities who play it. Readers have a chance to go against him each season in the Outpick the Picker contest. He welcomes the competition.
Follow The Picker on Twitter
Subscribe to this blog
Archive
Past Articles By The Picker
1/31/2013
The Picker: Super Bowl merely a distraction from OU woes
The Picker's Blog Archive:
2/2013
1/2013
12/2012
11/2012
10/2012
9/2012
8/2012
7/2012
6/2012
5/2012
4/2012
3/2012
2/2012
1/2012
12/2011
11/2011
10/2011
9/2011
8/2011
7/2011
6/2011
5/2011
4/2011
3/2011
2/2011
1/2011
12/2010
11/2010
10/2010
9/2010
8/2010
7/2010
6/2010
5/2010
4/2010
3/2010
2/2010
1/2010
12/2009
11/2009
10/2009
9/2009
8/2009
7/2009
6/2009
5/2009
4/2009
3/2009
2/2009
1/2009
12/2008
11/2008
10/2008
9/2008
8/2008
7/2008
6/2008
5/2008
4/2008
3/2008
2/2008
1/2008
12/2007
11/2007
10/2007
9/2007
8/2007
7/2007
6/2007
5/2007
4/2007
3/2007
2/2007
1/2007
12/2006
11/2006
10/2006
9/2006
8/2006
Home
|
Contact Us
|
Search
|
Subscribe
|
Customer Service
|
About
|
Advertise
Copyright
© 2013, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.