READ TODAY'S STORIES AND E-EDITION SUBSCRIBE |  CONTACT US |  SIGN IN
Sports Extra!



SPORTS EXTRA BLOGS

FOR THE RECORD
LOCAL PROS

ALL SPORTS

PHOTOS & VIDEOS

OUTDOORS

FIND A STORY

EMAIL ALERTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

RSS FEEDS

CONTACT US
BUY PHOTOS & PAGES

ADVERTISE ON SPORTS EXTRA


Print story only Print story with comments Email Twitter Facebook Pinterest
Tee It Up And Kick It
Published: 7/5/2007 5:17 PM
Last Modified: 7/5/2007 5:17 PM

A thought or two about OU-TU in Tulsa.


With a wild new coach and Paul Smith at quarterback, you actually have to give TU a shot here.


One thought about the TU quarterback and another about the no-huddle offense.


Last year, it appeared that Smith looked to scramble first and throw later, usually on the run. He needs to establish a pocket presence. Zing it first, scramble later.


The question about the no-huddle offense is a pretty simple one: What the?


It's awfully gimmicky.


What's wrong with taking a huddle and calling a play and kicking somebody's backside?


It's not like the other team doesn't know you're not huddling. They can see you not huddling. So they'll adjust and you'll adjust and you'll both adjust and then they'll throw a penalty flag, delay. You don't defeat quality teams with gimmicks, with several exceptions.


1. Bowl.


2. Boise.









Reader Comments 27 Total

Cherrypicker (6 years ago)
Miami, Florida played Oklahoma's wishbone in '75 and lost 20-17. They played Georgia Tech's wishbone the week before and lost 38-23. Difference? GT used a no-huddle offense...confused the bejesus out of Miami. But the 'hurry up' o takes lots and lots of practice and an almost intuitive communication on the offense. Good luck, TU.
TAB (6 years ago)
I'm not sure anyone has ever run anything quite like TU's new HUNH in college. Then again, I'm not sure many outside of Graham, Malzahn, Head, and Smith know much about this offense. While the Picker's point regarding the no huddle is well taken, if you take the time to read Malzahn's book (TAB has too much time on his hands), this is really a different way of looking at football. Instead of focusing on TOP, this system focuses on increasing your opportunities to score. TU could be one of those quirky teams, like Navy, Air Force, and Texas Tech, that you don't want to play because they are just different.
Jo (6 years ago)
Navy, Air Force,Tech......wow there's three tough teams!!
TAB (6 years ago)
Three teams that have been in bowls many of the last few years and that regularly upset supposedly bigger, badder teams. Tech beat the vaunted Sooners not too long ago. Do you disagree that these offenses can create problems? It's a COMPARISON to what a unique offense can do.
Jo (6 years ago)
These teams do not regularly upset better teams.Check your info.
worldpicker (6 years ago)
I tend to agree a little with Jo here about freaky teams. Texas Tech is only as good as its quarterback. Outside the dusty conference, Tech usually has trouble. Remember a couple of years ago in a Bowl, Tech made about four passing against a horrible Alabama team.



There's one big BUT here on the no-huddle: Indianapolis! That no-huddle seems to function pretty well for the Colts. This isn't to suggest that the TU quarterback is as good as Manning. And who knows how much Manning actually calls at the line, what with the microphones in the helmets. But this might be the one situation where you can out-scheme somebody. And pros have to be smarter, football-wise, than college guys. So upon further review, if you have sharp coaches and a talented quarterback, the no-huddle could drive somebody pretty good pretty nuts.

TAB (6 years ago)
Texas Tech 2005: OU, Nebraska
2004: Nebraska, Cal (who beat USC)

[p]
Navy just wins games.
[p]


My criteria was not an upset -- it was that teams win games because their system is difficult to adjust to. You have no response to that. Further, you have response to my analysis that this a point of comparison. You articulate no cogent response to the argument that teams with these quirky, but effective, offenses win games, in part because they are tough to prepare for.

[p]Now, Picker -- got a question. What do you think are the best burger joints in town?

worldpicker (6 years ago)
tab: Ron's burgers, where he mixes in sausage, will get your attention. Houligan's makes a nice, don't laugh, green bean cheeseburger! Also, they're excellent at Wild Fork at Utica.
ed (6 years ago)
I dont think Tech outsmarted OU in 05 or even close to it. OU kicked Techs you know what in previous years with the same offense. It was one game, one time, and one bull crap call. Actually, make that two bull crap calls.
TAB (6 years ago)
Yeah, I know all those places. You were so right on Bill Ray's -- a place I wrote off so long ago. The mediterranean burger at Wild Fork is freaking great. I really like Bill's as far as the greasy hole in the walls go.

My crieria was winning games. Tech stunk before they got that goofy offense. Now they go to bowls every year and can compete when they have decent talent. Then again, it appears the rest of college football is wising up to the Tech spread -- it might be like the wishbone in a few years. While I agree that call stunk against OU (both of 'em), OU did lose, just like they lost to Oregon. As far as I can see, you only get to claim one screw job a decade -- they happen, no doubt, but if it happens every year, you start to look like Arkansas fans.

Back to the topic, the question was whether this TU offense will work. If they run formations like that wildcat, it should be fun at least. They'll win games. Maybe upset someone every couple of years. At the very least, TU is stealing recruits from Arkansas which is just funny to watch.

worldpicker (6 years ago)
Ed, I agree, there's always this question looming, isn't there: Why hasn't the Tech coach been hired by a real school?

TAB: Yeah, the Billy Ray hot sauce is as good as it gets. Do try Houligan's, there's a steak night when big ones are reasonable, great local hang-out.....



TAB (6 years ago)
I know Brothers Houlighan well. Waffle fries and green beans and gravy. It's really the most underrated place in town.

Know clue why Leach hasn't left Lubbock. He's so weird, he might like it there. I thought Stanford would take him. I really like the guy -- he's just one of those colorful coaches and is willing to do things the old guard football types cringe at. That's a good thing. Plus, he's willing to play TU. We need more people like Leach and fewer Sabans and Mileses.

worldpicker (6 years ago)
All these fired coaches who never get hired anywhere else decent, and all the geniuses staying put, the marketplace is sometimes a pretty good judge.


worldpicker (6 years ago)
.....what about a McNellies burger?

steve dial (6 years ago)
I don't want you to think I am stupid or anythng like that, I am a loyal NFL fan and I also like some college football. I have been watching the sport for many years and there is one thing that I do not know and have never known. What is the difference between a wide receiver and a tight end ? Please answer this question for me, if you can. Well I know you probably can. I just hope you don't laugh it off as a joke. Thanks Steve Dial

Chris (6 years ago)
McNellie's burgers for $3 on Wednesday night is hands down the best deal in town, if you can get a table!


Ron's is top notch. Brownie's is pretty darn good too.

TAB (6 years ago)
I think McNellie's is fun, but their burger ain't all that. It's a cheap standard pub burger. So many places I'd go to before that. JJ's is fun, even though the guy is weirder than Mike Leach. I think Freddy's over on Lewis might be the best but I rarely go because they have weird hours. When I have people in Tulsa for the first time, we usually visit Weber's -- I've noticed quite a few fans of opposing schools attending TU games end up there. Can't go wrong with the root beer freeze.
Steven (6 years ago)
Picker:


I had thought that the microphone/speaker setup in NFL QB's helmets were for a very specific period of time and they were shut off after that (this is not to rebut your no-huddle suggestion...just that not sure that the helmet is continuing to work throughout the entire pre-snap play).


I understand the no-huddle can give most teams fits, but Stoops has done a pretty good job of preparing his troops for this offense before. Honestly, the biggest impediment to OU having it's way is not the offensive scheme...it is the absolute stellar play of P. Smith. That guy is incredible and I, for one, would love to have that talent and veteran leadership on OU's team this year. If TU keeps it close, it is because they have a QB, in P. Smith, that is more than solid and can make plays.


However, I still think TU will have a hard time dealing with this offensive line of OU's. Like OSU, nobody has been talking at all about how the defense is going to really play. I will be curious to see the first couple of weeks and how these 3 teams (OU, OSU and TU) handle some non-conference opponents.


burgers:
Webers, Ron's, Goldies, Ty's and still love Brownies.

Jeremy (6 years ago)
I got in on this blog a little late, but I'll chime in anyway.

TU has a chance to pull the shocker for two reasons:

1. Paul Smith

2. OU has not played TU well of late, so that must add to the confidence of Smith and the Golden Hurricane.

This is a game that can get out of hand if OU doesn't turn it over early and uses its superior talent edge in the trenches to muscle TU. But make no mistake...if OU makes a mistake or two early and lets TU hang around, Paul Smith could control the clock and stun the Sooners. I give TU a 10-15% chance.

As for "gimmick" offenses and defenses...this is what inferior teams must do to beat teams with better talent. I mean, it's simple. Tech or TU or Boise is not gonna line up against an OU or Alabama or USC and play them "straight up". They know coming in they must use finesse or tricks to get an edge. If these teams want a chance to beat a big dog, then they better so something out of the ordinary. Thus, practice it all year and hone it to perfection.

TAB (6 years ago)
The TU offense won't control the clock unless OU unexpectedly dumps the "COPS" offense. I agree that the OU o-line can create problems, especially with TU's similarly gimmicky 3-3-5 defense. There are two very contrasting styles of play. TU's only hopes are that OU doesn't decide to open up on offense and that it executes on offense. In order for that to happen, someone had better catch the ball for TU. This is the most inexperienced group of TU receivers in a long, long time.
worldpicker (6 years ago)
Steve: A tight end is the big guy on the short-side of the OU line off whose skull passes bounce.

G (6 years ago)
Now picker, I remember an OU tight end catching a ball 3 maybe 4 yrs ago.
Steven (6 years ago)
TAB n Jeremy:
Agreed.


TU doesn't have the receivers it has had in the past.

To that end, it also won't have the one player that torched OU. Garrett Mills has now moved on to giving opponents of the N.E. Patriots fits. Unless there is another Mills waiting in the wings somewhere that nobody has heard of, Smith's talent may be all for not.

Jeremy (6 years ago)
Well, I don't pretend to know much about TU's depth on the football roster or what they have returning. I just know how much of a gamer Paul Smith was last year, and how the TU players who were not recruited by OU will circle this game. If OU played TU the week after Miami, I'd give the Golden Hurricane an even better chance at the upset.

Who knows how the departure of Kragthorpe will affect TU's play. It can't be a positive. Like I said below, I give TU a 10-15% chance for now. OU can sure play to the level of their competition at times.

Changing the subject...how about that gutty performance by Lava Man in the Hollywood Gold Cup Mr. P? I love to watch horses that win races like he does. He's not close to the level of retired Invasor, because he can't win out of California, but man what a racehorse. By the way...as Lava Man heads to the Pacific Classic at Del Mar, I'll be hoping to find a shipper to beat him. He ran the final 1/8 mile in 25 seconds in the Gold Cup...that won't get it done against better than AP Excellent.

Sorry for the off the wall horse racing comments...I'm a big fan. The Rags to Riches and Lava Man races have made this a great year so far...

Jeremy (6 years ago)
Mr. P...I don't post on ESPN, so I'll comment on this blog about your most recent ESPN.com contribution.

I love your ideas about what horse racing needs. Does Fair Meadows put on a show...ever? Do they market? Do they give the casual gambler a reason to go to the races? Not that I see.

I often wager at a casino in NE Oklahoma where a full room of horse players can be witnessed on the weekends. But they (like me) are racing purists. Not there for the entertainment...but for the challenge of matching wits against the betting public and the track morning line maker.

I like the quality of racing at Hollywood Park and thus play races there often. That track has it figured out. True, it's built around the $$$ of LA...but Friday's post is 7:05pm locally, and a live band rocks the house after the last race.

Handicapping tournaments are out there...but not for the casual fan. Tracks and simulcast centers need to do a better job of drawing in casual fans. Poker is fine...I play myself. But I also play the ponies. There's room for both! Besides...more casual bettors make it a bit easier on handicappers like you and I, eh Mr. P??

25 of 27 comments displayed  |  View All


To post comments on tulsaworld.com, you must be an active Tulsa World print or digital subscriber and signed into your account.


Out Pick The Picker

The Picker began entertaining – and infuriating – sports fans in 1993. Each week during football season, he writes about his picks of college and NFL games in his Thursday Sports column. He's never afraid of sharing his opinions about the game and the personalities who play it. Readers have a chance to go against him each season in the Outpick the Picker contest. He welcomes the competition.

Follow The Picker on Twitter


Subscribe to this blog


Archive

Past Articles By The Picker

1/31/2013
     The Picker: Super Bowl merely a distraction from OU woes
 
The Picker's Blog Archive:

2/2013  1/2013  12/2012  11/2012  10/2012  9/2012  
8/2012  7/2012  6/2012  5/2012  4/2012  3/2012  
2/2012  1/2012  12/2011  11/2011  10/2011  9/2011  
8/2011  7/2011  6/2011  5/2011  4/2011  3/2011  
2/2011  1/2011  12/2010  11/2010  10/2010  9/2010  
8/2010  7/2010  6/2010  5/2010  4/2010  3/2010  
2/2010  1/2010  12/2009  11/2009  10/2009  9/2009  
8/2009  7/2009  6/2009  5/2009  4/2009  3/2009  
2/2009  1/2009  12/2008  11/2008  10/2008  9/2008  
8/2008  7/2008  6/2008  5/2008  4/2008  3/2008  
2/2008  1/2008  12/2007  11/2007  10/2007  9/2007  
8/2007  7/2007  6/2007  5/2007  4/2007  3/2007  
2/2007  1/2007  12/2006  11/2006  10/2006  9/2006  
8/2006  





Home | Contact Us | Search | Subscribe | Customer Service | About | Advertise
Copyright © 2013, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.