MAKE US YOUR HOMEPAGE
|
Tuesday, February 09, 2010
|
WIRELESS
CONTACT US
|
SUBSCRIBER SERVICES
|
SIGN IN
SIGN OUT
|
MY PROFILE PAGE
|
MY ACCOUNT
Advanced Search
Current Conditions
24°
(Feels like 17°)
5-day local forecast
Home
News
Sports
Business
Special Projects
Blogs
Scene
Obits
Videos
Photos
Databases
Opinion
Comics
Jobs
Autos
Homes
Classifieds
Contact Us
|
About the Tulsa World
|
FAQ & Help
|
Advertise With Us
|
Create an Online Account
|
Email Newsletters
|
RSS
|
Mobile
|
iPhone App
|
E-Edition
Local
|
State
|
US/World
|
Education
|
Health
|
Religion
|
Courts
|
Government
|
Stimulus Tracker
|
Weather
|
Births
|
Divorces
|
Marriages
|
Transitions
OU
|
OSU
|
TU
|
ORU
|
High Schools
|
College Football
|
College Basketball
|
Blogs
|
Out Pick the Picker Contest & Blog
|
NFL
|
Fantasy
|
Pros
|
Golf
|
Outdoors
|
Motor Sports
|
All
Stocks
|
Aerospace
|
Agriculture
|
Employment
|
Energy
|
Real Estate
|
Finance
|
Tech
|
Retail
|
Transportation
|
FYI
|
Consumer Awareness
|
Action Line
Special Projects
|
The Homicide Report
|
The SemGroup Collapse
|
Puppy Profits
|
The Life of Oral Roberts
|
The Life of Will Rogers
Sports
|
Scene
|
Opinion
|
Photo
Dining In
|
Dining Out
|
Movies
|
Music
|
On TV
|
The Arts
|
Style
|
People
|
Home
|
Health
|
Family
|
Books
|
Travel
|
Celebrations
|
Blogs
Obituaries
|
Memorials
|
Death Notices
|
Support
|
Resources
|
Funeral Directors Login
|
Search Obituaries
|
Find a funeral home or cemetery
|
Divorces
|
Marriages
|
Transitions
Videos
|
Blogs
Photos
|
Blogs
|
Order photo and page reproductions
Databases
|
State Salaries
|
City Salaries
|
Gas Station Violations
|
Crime Tracker
|
State Restaurant Inspection Reports
Editorials
|
Letters
|
Bruce Plante's Political Cartoons
|
Readers Forum
|
Wayne Greene's Blog
|
Mike Jones' Blog
|
Stems & Pieces
Comics Kingdom Online
|
Comics from the Tulsa World Print Edition
Job Search
|
Career Resources
|
Upload/Modify Resume
|
Hiring Companies
|
Career Fairs
|
Account Profile
|
Job Alerts
|
Employer Login
My Saved Searches
|
My Saved Ads
|
Boats
|
Motorcycles
|
Recreational Vehicles
|
Airplanes
|
Classic Cars
|
ATV's
|
Scooters
|
Sell Your Car
Property Search
|
Commercial Property
|
Foreclosures
|
World of Homes
|
Find a Realtor
|
Real Estate Login
Garage Sales
|
Pets
|
Post An Ad
|
Upload a Photo
|
Help & FAQ
Home
>
News
> Article
Newspaper View
Print
Email
Comment
RSS
Bookmark
If you would like to bookmark this article you will need to
Login
to your tulsaworld.com account
close
Ruling on open records is reversed
By ZIVA BRANSTETTER World Projects Editor
Published:
8/15/2007 2:43 AM
Last Modified: 8/15/2007 2:43 AM
OKLAHOMA CITY -- A state appeals court has reversed an Oklahoma County judge's ruling in the Tulsa World's open records lawsuit against the state Department of Public Safety.
The World filed the lawsuit in Oklahoma County District Court in 2001, seeking computerized and paper records on the department's use of force, stops, searches and agency procedures. The World sought the records to review the agency's treatment of minorities who were stopped and searched, among other issues.
Joe Worley, executive editor of the World, said the newspaper filed the suit on behalf of itself and the public.
"The public has an important interest in understanding the operations of state agencies such as the Department of Public Safety," he said. "We are glad that the court's decision has upheld that interest."
Oklahoma County District Judge Vicki Robertson had granted a motion for summary judgment in 2005, ruling that five types of records sought by the World were open records and three were not.
Robertson ruled that computerized traffic citation data, warning data and the department's policies and procedures manual were not open records.
The World and DPS both appealed Robertson's order, and a three-judge panel of the Court of Civil Appeals issued its ruling in the case Monday.
The judges ruled that Robertson's order granting summary judgment was in error because many facts in the case are in dispute.
The ruling states that the Open Records Act requires state agencies to segregate open records from those that are closed.
It notes that not all records possessed by a law enforcement agency fall under a limited list of law enforcement records that must be made public. In ruling that the entire operations manual is not an open record, Robertson erred, the court said.
The court returned the case to Robertson for further proceedings.
The court ruled that Robertson's findings regarding computerized data were flawed and reversed her ruling, sending the matter back for trial.
When it denied the World's request for the records, the Department of Public Safety said the data did not exist in the form requested, that it was a burden to produce, and that federal law prohibited the production of the data if it existed.
The court said the department's excuses for not providing the data were invalid.
The World's attorney, Schaad Titus, said the opinion clarified three points in the Open Records Act.
"Open records inside a computer data file are open records," he said. "It also clarifies that an agency has a duty to segregate and provide open information in computer files containing open and nonopen records."
The ruling also clarifies the law regarding law enforcement agency records. One section of the law contains eight categories of records that law enforcement agencies shall make available if kept.
Titus said the ruling notes that such agencies possess many other records that are not related directly to law enforcement.
"Not every piece of paper or document that a law enforcement agency has is a law enforcement record," he said. "There are all kinds of nonoperational, administrative, clerical and personnel information that are open records within a law enforcement agency."
Ziva Branstetter 581-8378
ziva.branstetter@tulsaworld.com
By ZIVA BRANSTETTER World Projects Editor
Copy Text
Search for this phrase/name
Close
Newspaper View
Print
Email
Comment
RSS
Bookmark
If you would like to bookmark this article you will need to
Login
to your tulsaworld.com account
close
Reader Comments
Show: Most Recent Comment First
Add your comment
1
comments have been made on this story so far. Tell us what you think below!
Reporting Comments
If you see a comment that violates our
terms and conditions
, please help us by clicking the "Report this Comment" link next to a comment. That will alert the web staff to review the comment. Thank you. --
Web Editor Jason Collington
Report Comment
JW
, (8/15/2007 2:45:00 PM)
did it for public interest eh? nah, I think Geico, Progressive, et al will be patting you on the back since you made it easier for them to do checks on their insured.
Add Your Comment
In order to post a comment on this article, you must
sign in to Tulsaworld.com
. If you do not have a site account, you can
create an account for free
.
Post Your Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Comments made yesterday
2,015
Total Comments
1,033,943
Register to make reader comments
1) Tulsa mayor wants to use grant money to hire back officers
2) Man arrested in Tulsa kidnapping also investigated in 2007 disappearance
3) Debating a penny
4) Tulsa man pleads guilty to murdering mom, cousin
5) Tulsa Denny's restaurant busy after Super Bowl ad promotion
6) Shawnee police shoot, kill knife-wielding man
7) Missing boy shows up at Oklahoma City school
8) Tulsa man, Coweta woman plead guilty in mortgage conspiracy
9) Two injured in highway crash
10) Tulsa team helps Haitian reportedly buried 22 days
View the top 50
These are the most viewed stories in the last 24 hours.
1) Tulsa police will not respond to some calls
2) Panel advances Bible-education bill
3) No cuts planned for mayor's staff
4) Gunman robs new north Tulsa grocery
5) Sarah Palin assails Obama at 'tea party' gathering
6) Tea Party movement looks to continue momentum
7) Officer out on bail after bar incident
8) Debating a penny
9) Most snow melts in mild storm
10) Tulsa mayor wants to use grant money to hire back officers
View the top 50
These are the top stories that have been commented on in the past 7 days.
1) Man arrested in Tulsa kidnapping also investigated in 2007 disappearance
2) Tulsa Denny's restaurant busy after Super Bowl ad promotion
3) Income tax credit: Making Work Pay
4) Tulsa team helps Haitian reportedly buried 22 days
5) Oklahoma legislature honors 'The Biggest Loser' winner
6) There's a job at the SHOP
7) Two Tulsa school board members unseated
8) Tulsa man, Coweta woman plead guilty in mortgage conspiracy
9) Debating a penny
10) Tulsa man pleads guilty to murdering mom, cousin
View the top 50
These are the top stories that have been emailed in the past 24 hours.
Home
|
About Tulsa World
|
Advertise With Us
|
Privacy
|
Usage Agreement
|
FAQ and Help
|
Contact Us
|
Today's Headlines
Copyright
© 2010, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.
Advanced Search