MAKE US YOUR HOMEPAGE | Tuesday, February 09, 2010 | WIRELESS CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBER SERVICES | SIGN IN SIGN OUT | MY PROFILE PAGE | MY ACCOUNT

Home > News > Article

Print this story Print      Email this story Email      Comment Comment      RSS RSS     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

Updated: Revised lawsuit against ORU makes new allegations

Dr. John Swails, left, Attorney Gary Richardson and Dr. Tim Brooker answer media question during a press conference at Richardsons Law Offices announcing their suit against Oral Roberts Univerisity on Oct. 2. Michael Wyke/Tulsa World
 
By Staff reports
Published: 10/12/2007  6:49 PM
Last Modified: 10/14/2007  5:35 AM



The latest on this story: School, Lindsay Roberts deny all



Document: Read the revised lawsuit.

For more: Read the latest stories, view the lawsuit and other documents and watch slide shows and video.


Three former Oral Roberts University professors have amended their lawsuit against the school, and have included an internal report detailing allegations against ORU President Richard Roberts, his wife and others.

The new suit adds a new defendant to the case -- the ORU regents -- and two new allegation, negligence and civil conspiracy.

Oral Roberts University officials, including President Richard Roberts, declined to comment after hours on Friday because they had not seen the amended lawsuit, a spokesman said.

The new suit includes a new allegation that Richard Roberts and ORU gave ''a convicted sexual deviant unrestricted access to the students of the university.''

The suit doesn't identify the person, but says that prior to his association with the school he had confessed to crimes in Tulsa, Tulsa County and Payne County.

''All three allegations of sexually-deviant conduct resulted in convictions,'' the suit says.

The person was hired at the direct personal instruction and under the supervision of Richard Roberts, the suit says.

The person, identified as a ''Mentor'' for ORU students, ''confessed to the facts regarding exposing himself to a fifteen year old boy in a school locker room,'' the suit says.

The suit also alleges that three days after the original lawsuit was filed earlier this month, the school's financial comptroller, a 26-year ORU employee, was fired.

''Within hours of this loyal employee's unceremonious removal from his office, witnesses have reported that voluminous materials and documents were shredded and destroyed....''

The new suit also includes a copy of a report one of the fired professors allegedly gave to ORU officials shortly before he was fired. The report says it is a Scandal Vulnerability Assessment and was prepared by Stephanie Cantees, Richard Roberts' sister-in-law and the community and governmental liaison for the Oral Roberts Ministry.

The report, which purports to be prepared by Cantees, misspells her name.

Most of the elements of the Cantees report are similar to allegations in an early version of the former professors' lawsuits, but more details are added to several of the allegations, especially allegations involved Lindsay Roberts and an unnamed teen boy.

The report says that dead-bolt locks were installed on all bedroom doors at the Richard Roberts residence at the insistence of his oldest daughter.

''This was precipitated by Mrs. Roberts repeatedly moving into the home her 16 year old male 'friend,' which made her daughters uncomfortable,'' the assessment says.

The assessment also says: ''Mrs. Roberts has personally spent the night in the ORU guest house with an underage male on nine separate occasions.''

The report also says there are photos of Lindsay Roberts and an underaged male smoking at the president's residence, and 29 photos of her and an underage male alone in her sports car after midnight.

The assessment goes on to say a longtime employee was fired so the same underage male companion could have the position.

The assessment also gives details concerning an electronic message Richard Roberts allegedly ordered ORU employees to post on the Mabee Center electronic marquee for his daughter, Chloe.

The message read, ''Matt, I sorry. Love, Chloe,'' the assessment says.

The report says the school received a total of 32 complaints about the message.

By Staff reports

Print this story Print      Email this story Email      Comment Comment      RSS RSS     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

Reader Comments
       Add your comment

128 comments have been made on this story so far. Tell us what you think below!

Report Comment Reporting Comments

If you see a comment that violates our terms and conditions, please help us by clicking the "Report this Comment" link next to a comment. That will alert the web staff to review the comment. Thank you.  -- Web Editor Jason Collington
 
 
Report Comment
d, Alabama (10/12/2007 7:05:07 PM)
Oh man, this is so bad.

I really believed that the text messages to an underage male probably came from one of the daughters, not her.

And who? pray tell was taking those pictures?

yikes

Report Comment
Barbara, Houston, TX (10/12/2007 7:28:17 PM)
This is really bad! However, every single one of those salactious allegations could turn out to be false, and yet Richard Roberts brought it on himself by firing someone just for giving the report to the Provost and Regents to investigate. He should have stepped off his man-made throne and allowed an investigation, and if/when the allegations were all proved to be false, he could have "suggested" to the professors that "they might be happier elsewhere," and they surely would have taken the hint.

But when you go off on a power-hungry rage, this is what happens!

Report Comment
Berean, Houston (10/12/2007 7:41:12 PM)
Nowhere in the Bible does the Lord guarantee that those doing His Work should get a tax-exempt status. According to this article, hundreds of tax-exempt ministries may now come under closer scrutiny by just about every kind of authority there is: IRS, state, local police, etc. And those that are found wanting shall be destroyed, only the true shall remain.

MENE, MENE, TEKEL, UPHARSIN

Report Comment
Former ORU Slave, Tulsa (10/12/2007 7:48:47 PM)
WOW!!! No big surprise. I worked at ORU and was disgusted from day 1. On my very first day, I saw the youngest Roberts daughter, Chloe, driving a Lexus SUV, when she was 16 years old!!! And Lyndsey driving a little red german sports car!!! And Tricky Dick with his entourage of cronies!!! Showing up at athletic events like he was the "King of the castle".

Richard Roberts is no more a holy-man, than I am the president of the United States. He's a preacher's kid (if you can even consider his daddy a preacher & not a crook/quack), that noticed that evangelism was where the money was. PERIOD!!! He was lazy & arrogant, and saw the way to make an easy buck. Riding daddy's coat-tails has brought him riches beyond most people's belief. And, now, his arrogance has brought about his undoing.

This whole debacle can be explained a very simple way. He & his (explicitive deleted) family thought they were above earthly & divine laws. And the idiots that have put up with their nonsense for so long should be ashamed of themselves. They've allowed this to happen. Just like they allow unqualified people to work in positions of power/stature at the university. Did you know that their hiring practice gives preference to ORU grads? Not really unheard of, but consider this. There are more than a dozen "professors" or "instructors" or "administrators" that have no higher than a bachelors degree. And that degree came from ORU. Not to mention that there are employees in one department that don't have so much as a bachelors degree, but are now in administrative positions, b/c "they've worked for the school for years, paid their dues, and deserve to be in charge." YEAH!!! In that same department, they've employeed someone for the better part of 40 years, and that person has never had to stay current with the guidelines or standards for their profession!!! It's a joke!

Report Comment
Q, (10/12/2007 7:51:02 PM)
Well, if all this is true, Dr. Swails and the other plaintiffs should be commended for going through all this to bring it to light. If it turns out to be false, or RR and LR somehow use their law team to get out of it, Dr. Swails and the other professors will be castigated. It's just a big mess at this point. Hopefully, a fair judge and jury will oversee all this.
Report Comment
Carl Robbins, San Joes (10/12/2007 8:04:26 PM)
THE TIP OF THE ICEBERG -- MORE TO COME

ORU is fast becoming the religious 'ENRON" in the eyes of most Americans. This amended suit -- and the unsavory details -- only hardens that view in the minds of Americans.

As at ENRON, the corruption and wrong-doing is at the top -- and some may wind up where others went for financial misdealings.

But the ones who will really suffer are those branded with the ORU/ENRON label. This may seem small in the small unreal world of evangelical/charismatics, but I can assure you when you go out into the real world, anything ---resume or degree-- with the Oral Roberts nameme on it will be scoffed at.

Now might be the time to disassociate yourselves from he ORU/ENRON debacle --- or be tarred with it.

Just my opinion of course, but I've seen how these things have played out.

You think this news was bad. Wait for more. it will come.

Report Comment
alum, former student worker, tulsa (10/12/2007 8:10:40 PM)
I cleaned, washed, waxed and refueled the "family" cars. I received no token payment from Richard. The cars were always filthy, drink spills, food was thrown all over inside the vehicle.
Report Comment
Scott, Tulsa (10/12/2007 8:13:33 PM)
Where is Stephanie Cantees, the author of the original report? When is she going to come forward and say whether the report was simply rumors that she collected, or facts that she can substantiate? Why hasn't Stephanie Cantees spoken up?
Report Comment
cindy, (10/12/2007 8:19:12 PM)
I believe that somehow God's grace will allow this university to survive. But if it falls, what happens to the alumni's diplomas. They are still good right? Just probably looked down upon.
Report Comment
Q, (10/12/2007 8:25:17 PM)
#8, Stephanie Cantees is the sister-in-law of Richard Roberts. She most likely will not say anything until she's forced to testify in a court of law.
Report Comment
FL ORU Alum, (10/12/2007 8:27:23 PM)
These allegations, even if true, are irrelevant to the plaintiffs' breach of contract cause of action. I believe they're hoping to try this case in the court of public opinion; thus, they release more and more outrageous scandalous tidbits about ORU. As an ORU alum, I am well aware that the Roberts' lifestyle was extravagant - much more than I thought appropriate, certainly. However, has anyone looked at what other college and university presidents and their families receive? Even at state (taxpayer-supported) schools, the mansions, free cars, fat expense accounts and the like for the presidents are the rule, NOT the exception. ORU isn't unique. It isn't even the worst, not by a long shot. I'm not excusing anything, but that's the way it is. It's a shame, especially when parents have to pay so much for their kids' tuition.
Report Comment
FL ORU Alum, (10/12/2007 8:31:32 PM)
As an alum, I don't worry that my ORU degree has been devalued one bit by this lawsuit. I was taught by qualified professors (none of the plaintiffs; I predate them) and earned a B.A. from an accredited university. Mrs. Robert's big clothes closet or the daughter's Lexus have no effect on that.
Report Comment
wilson, (10/12/2007 8:41:41 PM)
I know a lot of people (like you "former ORU slave") want to see the Roberts fall, but consider that there are thousands of good people who are either students or employees of ORU. It's very sad for them to have to deal with all of this.
Report Comment
Carl Robbins, San Jose (10/12/2007 8:44:17 PM)
Cindy --- post # 9 -- read my comment in post #6.

The small-world of like minds -- the evangelical bubble -- has insulated you from the way the "real" world -- see this shameful debacle. Don't kids yourselves. ORE is held in growing contempt in much of he "real" world. You may realize this only when you go out into that world with your resume or degree.

It's sad you, other students and alumni will bear this stigma. Closing ORU is not the tragedy. The impact on lives is.

Report Comment
Guillotine, (10/12/2007 8:45:16 PM)
#7: Hey, "alum, former student worker", I nominate you, citizen, to pull the lever on the leaders of the ancien régime! Vive la révolution!
Report Comment
wilson, tulsa (10/12/2007 9:02:41 PM)
Carl, #14, are you the arbiter of the "real world"? I'm curious why someone from San Jose would take such an interest in a small school like ORU. Do you have an axe to grind with "the evangelical bubble"? I would suggest that San Jose (I'm assuming California) is nothing like the "real world" of the midwest.
Report Comment
Susan, Franklin, Tenn. (10/12/2007 9:12:17 PM)
this is sad
Report Comment
amber, tulsa (10/12/2007 9:15:22 PM)
The midwest is the real world? Most people here cannot even find Iraq on a map!
Report Comment
formerorustudent, (10/12/2007 9:18:16 PM)
If the Roberts fall, it doesn't mean ORU will. I'm sorry, but the Roberts don't make ORU what it is... as you can see it is great despite them, definitely not because of them. Like Billy Joe said in chapel, ORU is God's university and its mission to go into every man's world is still a good thing that will survive even in light of this leadership corruption. No man is above the law, hopefully ORU will acquire honest and trust worthy leaders. Right now, we need the current "leaders" to show some humility and step down.
Report Comment
Guillotine, (10/12/2007 9:45:52 PM)
What this calls for is a six pack, some Bourbon and a couple of call girls!
Report Comment
What a hoot!, Tulsa (10/12/2007 9:59:37 PM)
Could this get any better...wheweeeeeeeee!

Hadn't had so much fun since the pigs ate my little sister!

(keep 'em coming #21)

Report Comment
Reaped & Sewed, Tulsa (10/12/2007 10:05:27 PM)
Yup...somebody is gonna get REAPED! big time in this deal. And sew it is.
Report Comment
nanny, Tulsa (10/12/2007 10:06:17 PM)
18. 10/12/2007 9:15:22 PM, amber, tulsa

The midwest is the real world? Most people here cannot even find Iraq on a map!

Most people in Tulsa can.

Report Comment
Great Balls a Fire, Tulsa (10/12/2007 10:07:02 PM)
Where is JERRY LEE LEWIS when we need him?
Report Comment
G, (10/12/2007 10:07:05 PM)
I don't see the "expanded" lawsuit as much different than the last one, other than to make it more "sensational", or try to have it appear "dicier". I also think that the 3 filing the suit don't really want to go to a trial, because they will also be examined as to how allegations were discovered, if there was any "doctoring" of any of the evidence, etc. It's pretty easy to alter writings on a computer document, etc.

It's also easy to "create" pictures or present them to look very incriminating. I realize this would be hard on the school as well as the Roberts, but I really want to see this go to trial, even though it's usually not the best way to handle things. However, it would need to be in front of a judge & jury that understands ethics, without favoring either side. Some accusations may be true, some not, but it's important to get a clearer picture. For example, what is the definition of daughter's "friends", etc? In a school like Victory, everybody in a class knows everybody. The most illogical thing that I see as I read comments is, how many are that interested, when they aren't even believers in any kind of morality at all, so why would they care if someone else is or isn't? (That was just a side comment.) In any case, it's time for a trial to be scheduled, imo. I still question what kind of "professors", or even a ligitimate ethical attorney would head for the press, before the accused even see the accusations, especially with rushed, sloppy papers like these? Very bizarre, & I think it's time for Richardson to be checked out by the Bar Association regarding his methods & tactics.

25 of 128 comments displayed. | View All

 

 
Add Your Comment 
In order to post a comment on this article, you must sign in to Tulsaworld.com. If you do not have a site account, you can create an account for free.

 
  
Post Your Comment
 


Most Popular Stories
Comments made yesterday 2,015
Total Comments 1,033,724
Register to make reader comments

Most Popular Stories




Tulsa World

Home | About Tulsa World | Advertise With Us | Privacy | Usage Agreement | FAQ and Help | Contact Us | Today's Headlines
Copyright © 2010, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.




Advanced Search