MAKE US YOUR HOMEPAGE | Wednesday, February 10, 2010 | WIRELESS CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBER SERVICES | SIGN IN SIGN OUT | MY PROFILE PAGE | MY ACCOUNT

Home > News > Article

Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email      Comment Comment      RSS RSS     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

Oklahoma's English-only amendment clears a hurdle
Changes to the proposal appear to have cleared up concerns that it would jeopardize federal funds.
 
By JIM MYERS World Washington Bureau
Published: 7/30/2009  2:35 AM
Last Modified: 7/30/2009  3:05 AM

WASHINGTON — Changes made to a proposed English-only constitutional amendment that's now headed to Oklahoma voters appear to resolve the concerns of a federal agency that had warned that it put federal funds in jeopardy.

"The proposal appropriately allows languages other than English when required by federal law, and, as long as recipients comply with those laws, federal funds are not at risk," U.S. Department of Justice spokesman Alejandro Miyar said Wednesday. "The issue we advised as creating potential confusion is no longer in the proposal."

Miyar said state lawmakers approved a different version about a week after the Justice Department sent a letter in April to Attorney General Drew Edmondson.

The letter advised that adoption of an earlier version of the amendment could conflict with Oklahoma's obligation to protect the civil rights of people with limited English proficiency.

It also reminded Edmondson that recipients of federal funds must comply with civil rights laws.

That letter was provided several weeks ago to the Oklahoma congressional delegation, and on Tuesday the delegation wrote to U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder and challenged his agency's right to threaten state funds pre-emptively.

In its letter, the delegation also asked Holder to identify which funds would be at risk, what prompted the letter to Edmondson, and whether other states with official English policies have received similar letters.

In response to questions from the Tulsa World, Miyar said the Department of Justice has a vigorous program of compliance to ensure that jurisdictions are aware of the requirements of the civil rights act.

However, Miyar said, the Oklahoma proposal was the only one the agency had noticed that cited a specific executive order.

That is why it was important to clarify to Oklahoma that Title VI, not the executive order, is the federal law that asserts the requirement for recipients of federal funds to provide reasonable access to people with limited English proficiency, Miyar said.

Asked whether other states had lost federal funds after adopting such laws, Miyar could not provide examples related to limited English proficiency but added that the Justice Department has found violations in many state facilities, such as courts and corrections departments.

"Terminating funds is the last option," Miyar said. "We work with the entities to obtain voluntary compliance."

U.S. Sen. Jim Inhofe, R-Okla., who led the delegation's effort to challenge the Justice Department, said he is pleased that the agency has called off its threat over the amendment.

"While the practical application of the state amendment is no different from what the Justice Department initially objected to, they have rightfully back-peddled from their threat to pull federal funding," Inhofe said.

"It was inappropriate in the first place for this federal agency to meddle in the affairs of our state."

Inhofe said he looks forward to the Department of Justice's response to the state delegation, adding that several questions contained in its letter remain unanswered.


Jim Myers (202) 484-1424
jim.myers@tulsaworld.com
By JIM MYERS World Washington Bureau

Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email      Comment Comment      RSS RSS     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

Reader Comments
       Add your comment

19 comments have been made on this story so far. Tell us what you think below!

Report Comment Reporting Comments

If you see a comment that violates our terms and conditions, please help us by clicking the "Report this Comment" link next to a comment. That will alert the web staff to review the comment. Thank you.  -- Web Editor Jason Collington
 
 
Report Comment
getreal, (7/30/2009 6:32:01 AM)
Now we just need to find someone in Okieville that speaks English.
Report Comment
Eagle 4, Tulsa (7/30/2009 7:19:37 AM)
"...state lawmakers approved a different version about a week after the Justice Department sent a letter in April..."

So, Inhofe "threw up his tail" and organized a protest weeks after the issue had been resolved. Typical.

It's all right, Jim - your faithful constituents are extremely weak with chronology. Your support will remain intact and, more importantly, your collection plates will remain overflowing. If you preach long enough, the Earth will be flattened.
Report Comment
:), (7/30/2009 8:36:09 AM)
So, the proposal has already been changed to comply with the Civil Rights Act. I guess he showed those feds... wait now, what is Inhofe whooping about, again?

The Hoff is pleased :)
Report Comment
A Concerned Citizen, (7/30/2009 11:02:31 AM)
I am puzzled as to what this law will mean for state agencies advertising overseas. Can OU and OSU write international recuitment materials in languages other than English? Can Oklahoma Tourism advertise outside of English-speaking countries?
Report Comment
Ignatz, Broken Bow (7/30/2009 11:23:22 AM)
I would be all for this if it imposed on current Oklahoma born citizens the obligation to pass a simple English proficiency test or be sterilized and denied the right to vote.
Report Comment
billy8, Sand Springs (7/30/2009 11:47:19 AM)
What about all those kids who are graduating from high school and still can't read and speak correctly?
Report Comment
your kidding, Owasso (7/30/2009 2:49:58 PM)
Does this mean Owasso will have to take doen those stupid "Character Traits" banners that are in spanish? What a joke the whole City of Characters thing is anyway. The City Manager should compare himself to some of those traits before hyping them to others.
Report Comment
my view, Sand Springs (7/30/2009 4:19:03 PM)
Twenty-eight states have passed English only laws, Oklahoma will be added to that list making it number 29. If you were to break down the numbers in percentages we have at this moment 56 percent of the nation with English only laws, adding Oklahoma to the list will make 58 percent.

That would make the remaining 21 states in the minority. Just like those that are against the measure here in Oklahoma in the minority.
Report Comment
JB, Chicago (7/30/2009 4:32:14 PM)
Hi, welcome to Oklahoma. English only please, we hate foreigners.
Report Comment
Ayo, T-Town (7/30/2009 4:48:23 PM)
>>>>>"It was inappropriate in the first place for this federal agency to meddle in the affairs of our state."

Not if your state thinks it can stomp on federal civil rights.

If you people don't like that then don't take federal funds in the first place.
Report Comment
tfromtulsa, Tulsa (7/30/2009 6:23:01 PM)
my view - Good point.
Report Comment
Woofenburger, Hominy (7/30/2009 8:43:36 PM)
About 25 or 30 years ago there were Cherokee families living in the hills in eastern Oklahoma that did not speak english. When their children came to kindergarden the first thing they had to learn was to speak english.

I wonder if some of those folks are still around and how it will affect them.
Report Comment
stormytyca, Tulsa (7/30/2009 9:59:03 PM)
(I'm listing these as going there permanently... not if you're on "vacation") If you go to France, you learn French. If you go to Germany, you learn German. If you go to Russia... the list goes on. If you are going to come to America on a permanent basis, LEARN ******* ENGLISH!

I am sick and tired of having to spend 30 minutes drawing things so I can give someone directions who knows a total of about 15 english words... seriously people.

Is it really that much to ask that you learn the language of the country you are moving to?
Report Comment
mike2000, (7/30/2009 10:21:53 PM)
English Only will pass in this state by a wide margin. Get over it. We can take those ridiculous Spanish language signs down in downtown Tulsa. We can have immigrants make just a little bit of effort to learn the language. Is that asking so much?
Report Comment
Daniel Day Simpson, Edmond (7/30/2009 11:16:17 PM)
Woofenburger, Hominy (7/30/2009 8:43:36 PM)
Isn't that a historical hot button issue with the tribes? Kids not learning their own language and it becoming lost? How about the history of forced education where Indian children were forced to give up their own language and learn English. O.U. has placed great importance on students taking a native American language as their "foreign" language. O.U. puts so much importance on it that they have lessened the requirement if you choose a native language over a Latin, Germanic, or other non-native language. So that means if you are in College of A&S if you take something like Spanish, you will be required to take 3 semesters. If you take something like Cherokee, you only have one semester to take. Of course it will eat your lunch but its worth it.
Report Comment
Daniel Day Simpson, Edmond (7/30/2009 11:18:13 PM)
Forgot to mention that most of the native languages are not taught on campus. You must travel to a tribal learning center to attend the class. But they are working on online courses also and may already offer them.
Report Comment
tulsaworker1, (7/30/2009 11:28:26 PM)
S.I. Hayakawa recommended making the national language english two decades ago. As a japanese american and college professor, he felt it would do more to help the melting pot than continue to build enclaves of americans who can't speak english and instead of promoting and paying for illegals to function in our society. It doesn't restrict other languages, it just says that we don't have to cater to other languages. To function in the united states you should be able to speak and read english, end of story.
Report Comment
:), (7/31/2009 6:57:06 AM)
mike2k, what has no teeth, no weight and is totally irrelevant?

The latest version of ok's english only amendment! LOL!

Sure this will pass! The sun will rise in the east and absolutely nothing will change. You see, the amendment's impotence is the funny part! Get it? You might as well vote on the official sky color of okiehoma.
Report Comment
A Concerned Citizen, (7/31/2009 9:35:55 AM)
So, will Oklahoma colleges be able to write recruitment materials for non-English speaking countries? Will Oklahoma tourism be able to advertise in other languages? If not, it seems silly to limit ourselves.
 

 
Add Your Comment 
In order to post a comment on this article, you must sign in to Tulsaworld.com. If you do not have a site account, you can create an account for free.

 
  
Post Your Comment
 


Most Popular Stories
Comments made yesterday 2,108
Total Comments 1,034,052
Register to make reader comments

Most Popular Stories




Tulsa World

Home | About Tulsa World | Advertise With Us | Privacy | Usage Agreement | FAQ and Help | Contact Us | Today's Headlines
Copyright © 2010, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.




Advanced Search