READ TODAY'S STORIES AND E-EDITION SUBSCRIBE |  CONTACT US |  SIGN IN
Print story only Print story with comments Email Facebook

Senate OKs bill allowing health-care reform suit


By BARBARA HOBEROCK World Capitol Bureau


OKLAHOMA CITY — A measure allowing the Legislature to sue the federal government over recently enacted health-care reform is headed to Gov. Brad Henry's desk.



The Oklahoma Senate on Tuesday approved House Joint Resolution 1054, which is designed to allow citizens to opt out of federal health-care reform.

"It would prevent the federal government from forcing any Oklahoman to participate in any health-care system," said Sen. Randy Brogdon, R-Owasso, who is running for governor. "It would also prohibit the federal government from dictating how doctors choose to care for their patients.

"Finally, the measure authorizes the leaders of the Legislature to hire outside counsel to represent Oklahoma in a lawsuit to prevent 'Obamacare' from being forced on our state."

Oklahoma Attorney General Drew Edmondson, a Democrat who is running for governor, reviewed the federal law and said a lawsuit would likely fail and would waste resources.

Brogdon, a Senate author of the bill, said the Goldwater Institute has offered to represent the state at no cost.

Rep. Mike Ritze, R-Broken Arrow, is a House author of the bill.

Sen. Richard Lerblance, D-Hartshorne, said federal law is the supreme law of the land and supersedes state law.

He said the state recently passed lawsuit reform to deal with frivolous lawsuits but that there is no evidence it has reduced the cost of health care or resulted in health insurance for more Oklahomans.

"Mark my words: People will be out on a limb to pay to prosecute this frivolous lawsuit," Lerblance said.

Sen. Judy Eason McIntyre, D-Tulsa, called the measure a "very, very, bad, bad bill."

"It does nothing but to incite the people," she said.

She said lawmakers have the opportunity to do something other than "use this hot-button issue to garner political support."

Brogdon said federal health-care reform creates socialized medicine and destroys the free market. He said he is trying to protect the state's sovereignty.

The measure passed by a vote of 25-17.


Barbara Hoberock (405) 528-2465
barbara.hoberock@tulsaworld.com

Copyright 2012 World Publishing Co. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Reader Comments 58 Total

Some reader comments for this page were copied from "Bill allowing state to sue feds over health-care reform sent to governor," which was published on 5/4/2010.

Denver918 (2 years ago)
Veto this bill Governor. Federal law supersedes state law, suing will get you nowhere.
BlackJack (2 years ago)
Obama - take notes. This is what happens when a government does what the people want, not what a government does to its people who don't want it.
seymore1965 (2 years ago)
We need this healthcare. I'm willing to see what happens.
top_hatter (2 years ago)

Once again our morons in OKC feel the need to waste more money we don't have.
Aren't there enough states in this legal action now? Why waste the money? We will have our lots cast with those filing suit allready.
okpaul (2 years ago)
Gov. Henry, Please, please, please veto this bill. Brodgon and Ritze are an embarrasement to this state!
Hanuman (2 years ago)
Somebody needs to give this Brogdon guy a rabies test.
jaenosjelantru (2 years ago)
"the Goldwater Institute has offered to represent the state at no cost."

No cost. Sign it.
PrairieGirl (2 years ago)
Our state is getting more stupid by the moment!
kunta (2 years ago)
Professing to be wise, they became fools, and changed the glory of the
incorruptible God into an image made like corruptible man- and birds and
four footed animals and creeping things.
Therefore God also gave them up to uncleanness, in the lusts of their
hearts, to dishonor their bodies among themselves, who exchanged the
truth of God for the lie, and worshiped and served the creature rather
than the Creator, who is blessed forever, Amen

This explains our dilemma very accurately.

GREAT QUOTE

( Too bad we don't know who wrote it....)


"The danger to America is not Barack Obama but a citizenry capable of
entrusting a man like him with the presidency. It will be easier to limit
and undo the follies of an Obama presidency than to restore the necessary
common sense and good judgment to an electorate willing to have such a
man
for their president.


The problem is much deeper and far more serious than Mr. Obama, who is a
mere symptom of what ails us. Blaming the prince of the fools should not
blind anyone to the vast confederacy of fools that made him their prince.


The republic can survive a Barack Obama. It is less likely to survive a
multitude of fools such as those who made him their president."
Biker Patriot (2 years ago)
Another bill the empty suit needs to sign...
mlwells (2 years ago)
"It would also prohibit the federal government from dictating how doctors choose to care for their patients." But, it's okay for Oklahoma legislators to dictate how doctors care for their (women) patients?!

"...the state recently passed lawsuit reform to deal with frivolous lawsuits but that there is no evidence that it has reduced the cost of health care or resulted in health insurance for more Oklahomans." Surprise! And, the "reform" amounted to Oklahoma taxpayers picking up the tab for malpractice awards in excess of the "cap". Oklahoma physicians now only need maintain $400,000 in malpractice coverage (versus the previous $1 million ... still haven't heard from anyone that his/her charge for an office visit was reduced). Oklahoma taxpayers are subsidizing the difference! The insurers of Oklahoma didn't lose a cent! But, that's what the Okie yahoos wanted!

Roots (2 years ago)
This has VETO written all over it.

Please don't let us down Gov. Henry.
tea party (2 years ago)
Seymore1965...Do you know what this healthcare bill is going to do to Senior Citizens?????? I am seventy-seven years old and have been told by two of my Doctors that they are considering either retiring or changing fields!!! There is already a shortage of family physicians and they are adding thirty million more people to healthcare??? My Dr said he would have to call a mediating board (approved by the Obama administration) to get an approval to treat me in the manner he deams necessary. I heard Obama, myself, say that some of us would probably have to take pain pills instead of having hip surgery or whatever treatment I needed. They (Obama administration) are taking fify billion dollars out of the medicare system in order to set up another
Medicaid type account...there will be nothing left to treat to senior citizens!!! I agree we need healthcare reform...why don't they correct the flaws in our current system instead of starting from scratch??? Eighty percent of the American people are satisfied with their insurance they have now!!!!
Have a heart for the ones of us who will suffer the most!!! The Obama administration has put the senior citizens on the "death" list and most of us have no other means of paying for our illnesses. DO YOU CARE SEYMORE1965?
tea party (2 years ago)
Another thing...did any of you hear about what Congress has done to themselves. Someway they fouled up and block themselves from any insurance. They will not be eligible until 2014. The chickens have come home to roost!!!
Razor1911 (2 years ago)
“It would also prohibit the federal government from dictating how doctors choose to care for their patients."

Interesting comment from Sen. Brogdon.

However, it does seem to contradict the recent abortion legislation, that the Senator supported...that would prevent a doctor from advising his client.....
Hal Jordan (2 years ago)
Randy Brogdon wants a Civil War. The man is crazy.

Ditto the comment about the abortion legislation.


tea party (2 years ago)
Razor1911...My Doctor told me he had been to a meeting with a large group of Doctors and they were all told that their decision of how to treat their patients will have to be ruled on by the government mediating board and their decision could be in favor of the treatment wanted by the Doctor or the board may rule differently. So...the government board has the last word.
History (2 years ago)
I think they ought to pay the costs of their lawsuits themselves. I don't want them wasting my money on their stupidity. They obviously need to take the office of Oklahoma Attorney General off the ballots and do away with the office. After all, when you have so many know-it -alls in the legislature, you don't need legal counsel. Just hire the Goldwater Institute to represent them. But make no mistake, the people of OK will pay for their legal representation. These kind of groups never do anything out of the kindness of their hearts. I think I'll ask the U.S. Attorney-General's office to protect my rights if OK. tries to keep me from participating in the federal health-care system.
Razor1911 (2 years ago)
tea, I was merely pointing out the hypocrisy of Sen Brogdon's comments...if you are too dense to see that, then you are the epitome of the myopic one-track mindset of your movement....
tea party (2 years ago)
Razor1911...Takes one to know one...and you don't complete your sentences with a period(?). Never know if your thoughts are completely finished!
Skeptic (2 years ago)
Let me think....hmm tea party, I'll bet your doctor is a Republican. I'll bet he is one who hates socialized medicine so much that he has written protest letters against the looming Medicare payment cuts.

Oklahoma legislators, reducing Oklahoma one lame lawsuit at a time. Please veto this crude of a bill, Governor!
redbeard (2 years ago)
Make no mistake....all Brogdon cares about is winning the next election. He could care less if people have health care or not.

Veto this bill Gov. Henry.
tea party (2 years ago)
Skeptic...Wrong, wrong, wrong! My doctor and I are both independents...we both left the democratic party. I was a registered and voting democrat for about fifty years and suddenly I could no longer recognize the Democrat party...so, I am now a registered Independent.
Want to shake the cobwebs out of your brain and think it over again????
tea party (2 years ago)
Redbeard...Do you mean Brodgon "could care less" or he "couldn't care less."
Hanuman (2 years ago)
Tea Party, apparently you don't recognize that your insurance company decides on what treatments you can and can't have NOW -- based on what is most profitable for them. An independent non-profit mediating board, if there really is such a thing, would undoubtedly render better decisions for patients.
25 of 58 comments displayed  |  View All


To post comments on tulsaworld.com, you must be an active Tulsa World print or digital subscriber and signed into your account.
 

Newsletter Sign up
Get breaking news email alerts
When significant news breaks locally, get an alert and link to the story.
  
Most Popular Stories
Most Viewed
Most Commented
 
View the Top 50
These are the most viewed stories in the last 24 hours.







Home | Contact Us | Search | Subscribe | Customer Service | About | Advertise | Privacy
Copyright © 2012, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.