MAKE US YOUR HOMEPAGE
|
Saturday, November 21, 2009
|
WIRELESS
CONTACT US
|
SUBSCRIBER SERVICES
|
SIGN IN
SIGN OUT
|
MY PROFILE PAGE
|
MY ACCOUNT
Advanced Search
Current Conditions
54°
(Feels like 54°)
5-day local forecast
Home
News
Sports
Business
Special Projects
Blogs
Scene
Obits
Videos
Photos
Databases
Opinion
Comics
Jobs
Autos
Homes
Classifieds
Contact the Tulsa World
|
User Guide
|
About the Tulsa World
|
FAQ & Help
|
Advertise with us
|
Create an Online Account
|
Email Newsletters
|
RSS
|
Wireless
Local
|
State
|
US/World
|
Education
|
Health
|
Religion
|
Courts
|
Government
|
Stimulus Tracker
|
Weather
|
Births
|
Divorces
|
Marriages
OU
|
OSU
|
TU
|
ORU
|
High Schools
|
College Football
|
College Basketball
|
Blogs
|
Out Pick the Picker Contest & Blog
|
NFL
|
Fantasy
|
Pros
|
Golf
|
Outdoors
|
Motor Sports
|
All
Stocks
|
Aerospace
|
Agriculture
|
Employment
|
Energy
|
Real Estate
|
Finance
|
Tech
|
Retail
|
Transportation
|
FYI
|
Consumer Awareness
|
Action Line
Special Projects
|
The Homicide Report
|
The SemGroup Collapse
|
Puppy Profits
|
The Life of Oral Roberts
|
The Life of Will Rogers
Sports
|
Scene
|
Opinion
|
Photo
Dining In
|
Dining Out
|
Movies
|
Music
|
On TV
|
The Arts
|
Style
|
People
|
Home
|
Health
|
Family
|
Books
|
Travel
|
Celebrations
|
Blogs
Death Notices
|
Paid Obituaries
Videos
|
Blogs
Photos
|
Blogs
|
Order photo and page reproductions
Databases
|
State Salaries
|
City Salaries
|
Gas Station Violations
|
Crime Tracker
|
State Restaurant Inspection Reports
Editorials
|
Letters
|
Bruce Plante's Political Cartoons
|
Readers Forum
|
Wayne Greene's Blog
|
Mike Jones' Blog
|
Stems & Pieces
Comics Kingdom Online
|
Comics from the Tulsa World Print Edition
Job Search
|
Career Resources
|
Upload/Modify Resume
|
Hiring Companies
|
Career Fairs
|
Account Profile
|
Job Alerts
|
Employer Login
My Saved Searches
|
My Saved Ads
|
Boats
|
Motorcycles
|
Recreational Vehicles
|
Airplanes
|
Classic Cars
|
ATV's
|
Scooters
|
Sell Your Car
Property Search
|
Commercial Property
|
Foreclosures
|
World of Homes
|
Find a Realtor
|
Real Estate Login
Garage Sales
|
Pets
|
Post An Ad
|
Upload a Photo
|
Help & FAQ
Home
>
Opinion
> Article
Newspaper View
Print
Email
Comment
RSS
Bookmark
If you would like to bookmark this article you will need to
Login
to your tulsaworld.com account
close
Tar Creek afterlife
Will cleanup efforts work?
By World's Editorial Writers
Published:
10/9/2009 2:22 AM
Last Modified: 10/9/2009 4:15 AM
The town of Picher, epicenter of one of the largest environmental disasters in the nation, technically ceased to exist last month. Area residents are being removed from harm's way, but the mess remains to clean up.
Mining caverns, bore holes, acres of leftover tailings and monstrous chat piles remain, signifying a place of vast mineral wealth that turned into vast mineral waste.
More than $100 million has been spent by the federal government trying to clean up the 43-square mile Ottawa County mining district, once one of the nation's top suppliers of zinc and lead. Both the land above and the soil below are constant threats. Water quality is impaired. Even vegetation is a source of concern.
But there is promising work afoot. Unlike dozens of cleanup projects in the past — which failed or fell far short of their goal — a new $1.2 million passive, organic water treatment system has cleaned up one-fifth of contaminants that enter into the lead- and zinc-polluted Tar Creek stream.
Robert W. Nairn with the University of Oklahoma Center for Restoration of Ecosystems and Watersheds says that's significant: "I believe it is a successful project but we will know more when we come back in five years."
The project, operational for about a year, is designed to remove 200 pounds of aluminum, 40 pounds of arsenic, eight pounds of cadmium, 105,000 pounds of iron, 500 pounds of nickel, 33 pounds of lead and 6,000 pounds of zinc every year.
The design life for the innovative
treatment plant is 30 years. That's a pretty good return on a $1.2 million investment. And even better still, it's working.
Miami, Okla., Mayor Brent Brassfield, who toured the plant recently, believes the process should be used on the entire Tar Creek area. That's certainly an appealing idea.
Unlike the Environmental Protection Agency's almost worthless and costly efforts to remove contaminated top soil from yards, this modest project is the little engine that could.
The OU project appears to be succeeding where bureaucracy failed.
By World's Editorial Writers
Newspaper View
Print
Email
Comment
RSS
Bookmark
If you would like to bookmark this article you will need to
Login
to your tulsaworld.com account
close
Reader Comments
Show: Most Recent Comment First
Add your comment
7
comments have been made on this story so far. Tell us what you think below!
Reporting Comments
If you see a comment that violates our
terms and conditions
, please help us by clicking the "Report this Comment" link next to a comment. That will alert the web staff to review the comment. Thank you. --
Web Editor Jason Collington
Report Comment
Loki
, Broken Arrow (10/9/2009 2:54:01 AM)
There is something appealing in using a natural process to mediate our unnatural spoiling of the sites.
One hopes we get smarter as we confront this all-too-common industrial blight. We learn slowly, but perhaps we eventually absorb the lessons (along with the lead).
Laissez-Faire leaves a mark. And it puts the public at the tender mercies of groups who follow one principle: profit over all other considerations.
Report Comment
LEO
, (10/9/2009 8:33:08 AM)
I would like to thank OU and Mr. Naim for taking an idea that I present to EPA several years ago as a way to help in stopping disgharges from Tar Creek to downstream water impoundments, which EPA said was not a permanent solution for Tar Creek and would not use and does not follow Federal law, so I could finish with a permanet solution I was developing. I do not how you got EPA to approve this and I am not trying to take any credit for what you have done, but I am very pleased that you did a project at Tar Creek that the EPA said they would not do and take this project somewhere else. My hat is off to you. EPA needs and the Person directly in charge of the EPA (President Obama) needs to understand that there are many in Oklahoma that care and can provide inovation that will benefit environment problems like Tar Creek. THANKS LEO BYFORD
Report Comment
Skyhawk
, Downtown Tulsa (10/9/2009 11:38:06 AM)
Thank you Senator Inhofe.
You have saved lives in your district and have managed to obtain continual funding for this project! All by working WITH three different administrations.
Job well done!
I am sorry for all those that had to leave their homes. In the 1900's thru 30's, we didn't know what we didn't know. We know now.
Hopefully, Senator Inhofe will continue to request funding to continue his good work!
Report Comment
tulsaGuy
, (10/9/2009 12:37:54 PM)
Anybody checked to see if the Picher Housing Authority, etc. are still getting federal funds?
Report Comment
Polar Bear
, (10/9/2009 2:10:35 PM)
Why do companies get to mie,make a mess and then have others pay...even with their life and health.The nuclear industry refuses to accept responsibility for shabby building practices..Still our reps in Conrress look the other way.Little guys always pay..
Report Comment
okie ridgerunner
, Small Country Town State Line (10/9/2009 3:43:39 PM)
I drive thru picher once or twice a week. and there are still quite a few people living there.hud still has people in the low income apts and the drug rehab still has several people living there.there is not much being done there. but there are several people still around.
Report Comment
WhoseLeft
, Tulsa (10/9/2009 10:21:29 PM)
Skyhawk,
Are you speaking ironically? Senator Jim was the one who wanted to keep piling new top soil on top of the contamination.
My memory is that he was opposed to moving people out of Picher. New dirt, that was the solution that failed for decades. Of course, it spured a whole new industry in moving dirt.
Add Your Comment
In order to post a comment on this article, you must
sign in to Tulsaworld.com
. If you do not have a site account, you can
create an account for free
.
Post Your Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Mike Strain
Good e-mails: Quarterback issues and Mangino woes
Dave Sittler
What The Heck Was Gundy Thinking?
John Klein
Not Pretty But it Is a Win
The Picker
Team Pansy
Jimmie Tramel
Cheater (the one in the hoodie) doesn't prosper
Comments made yesterday
1,932
Total Comments
895,940
Register to make reader comments
1) New York Terrorist Trial
2) Victory
3) Reasonable
4) Letter to the Editor: Shame on Coburn, Inhofe
5) Letter to the Editor: Time for health care reform
6) Letter to the Editor: Judge not
7) Rainy Day Fund
8) Letter to the Editor: Thanks, team
9) Letter to the Editor: In defense of Lauinger
View the top 50
These are the most viewed stories in the last 24 hours.
1) Letter to the Editor: Fox’s ‘millions’
2) What the Right want
3) Back in the day
4) New York Terrorist Trial
5) Rainy Day Fund
6) Coburn the Budget Hawk
7) Letter to the Editor: Mandatory vasectomies
8) Letter to the Editor: Blame Coburn
9) Letter to the editor: Column lacked credibility
10) Letter to the Editor: Time for health care reform
View the top 50
These are the top stories that have been commented on in the past 7 days.
1) New York Terrorist Trial
2) Victory
3) To dream in America
4) Reasonable
5) Letter to the Editor: Thanks, team
6) Can we really stop climate change?
View the top 50
These are the top stories that have been emailed in the past 24 hours.
Home
|
About Tulsa World
|
Advertise With Us
|
Privacy
|
Usage Agreement
|
FAQ and Help
|
Contact Us
|
Today's Headlines
Copyright
© 2009, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.
Advanced Search