MAKE US YOUR HOMEPAGE | Friday, November 20, 2009 | WIRELESS CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBER SERVICES | SIGN IN SIGN OUT | MY PROFILE PAGE | MY ACCOUNT

Home > Opinion > Article

Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email      Comment Comment      RSS RSS     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

The devil you say
 
By Staff reports
Published: 4/2/2009  4:29 AM
Last Modified: 4/2/2009  4:29 AM

The demonization of tobacco is not straight news. Demonization (a subset of "card stacking" propaganda) may have its place on the editorial page, but not on the front page.

The latest example of this was the Tulsa World's March 27 front-page report that "Smoking is the leading preventable cause of death in Oklahoma data shows." Putting aside the incorrect grammar ("data" is plural), the statement begs the question: what data?

Readers who seek facts rather than bending to propaganda would be interested in knowing "who says and how come?" We are in a distinct minority, but some of us actually read the "studies" that present tobacco as the ultimate health evil.

Reporters who cite studies associated with tobacco should name them and identify the sources. Some smokers actually read those studies to make up their own minds as to whether the data are compelling, or just more of the demonization that blames tobacco for everything from lung cancer to a bad haircut.

Here's an "inconvenient truth." No causal relationship has ever been clinically established between tobacco use and disease of any kind. All the studies referred to in the demonization of tobacco are epidemiological (statistical).

There is a statistical "link" between tobacco and disease, but it is compromised by confounding factors that plague multifactorial epidemiology. This doesn't faze the demonizers, but I expect better from straight news reporting.

Whew! I feel better already. I'd like a smoke.

Ken
Frakes, Tulsa



Letters to the editor are encouraged. Each letter must be signed and include an address and a telephone number where the writer can be reached during business hours. Addresses and phone numbers will not be published. Letters should be a maximum of 200 words to be considered for publication and may be edited for length, style and grammar. Letters should be addressed to Letters to the Editor, Tulsa World, Box 1770, Tulsa, Okla., 74102, or send e-mail to letters@tulsaworld.com.

By Staff reports

Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email      Comment Comment      RSS RSS     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

Reader Comments
       Add your comment

17 comments have been made on this story so far. Tell us what you think below!

Report Comment Reporting Comments

If you see a comment that violates our terms and conditions, please help us by clicking the "Report this Comment" link next to a comment. That will alert the web staff to review the comment. Thank you.  -- Web Editor Jason Collington
 
 
Report Comment
hush, Tulsa (4/2/2009 5:41:53 AM)
Ken. Your argument about the confounding factors of multifactorial epidemiology is taken directly from a 1972 big tobacco memo known as The Roper Proposal in which big Tobacco Institue proposed "The Multi-factorial Hypothesis". The intent of which was to create "credible alternatives" to the insurmountable amount of scientific data which shows clear, convincing, causal relationship to smoking and disease.

Come on man, we have known tobacco kills people since the 1950's. Put down your Philip Morris mantra, let the smoke clear, and maybe you will see things more clearly.
Report Comment
Ignatz, Broken Bow (4/2/2009 7:54:57 AM)
I know Mr. Frakes, a right wing chain smoker, but a generally good conversation partner. Only man I know who has fired an AK-47. Says it is a pos. Anyway,all the big ciggie ceos have already owned up to tobacco's addicitive cancer causing agents so that's moot. Any book on the subject details other health problems. Like so many addicts, Mr. Frakes is in serious denial. He's in his 60's so probably whistling past the grave yard.
Report Comment
Graychin, Eucha (4/2/2009 8:30:52 AM)
Mr. Frakes, does drunk driving cause auto accidents? The proof is only statistical. Many people drive drunk and don't have accidents. Accidents happen to people who aren't drunk.

Does obesity cause heart attacks? The evidence is only statistical. Does sun exposure cause skin cancer? The evidence is only statistical.

Your argument about tobacco is the dumbest argument I have ever heard, bar none. Statistics isn't that advanced a concept. It's actually very easy to understand than many more advanced ideas, like a Copernican solar system.
Report Comment
Graychin, Eucha (4/2/2009 8:32:09 AM)
WHO CHOOSES THESE LETTERS FOR PUBLICATION? AND WHY?
Report Comment
justiceawaits, Claremore (4/2/2009 8:32:33 AM)
Just keep raising the tax on tobacco, won`t be too much longer until we will be smuggling it in from Mexico just like weed. Seriously people, did You learn nothing from Prohibition and the way it fueled organized crime?
Report Comment
tulsa citizen, (4/2/2009 8:44:43 AM)
Well Ken - all I can say is..... spoken like a true addict. Whatever you have to keep telling youself that smoking is okay so you can sleep at night is what people deep in addiction keep telling themselves. Sure you want a smoke after writing you piece of fiction, YOU ARE A DRUG ADDICT! I can't wait until the FDA finally regulates tobacco!!!!
Report Comment
droopy, wagoner (4/2/2009 9:39:17 AM)
More from the mean spirited libs. Who chooses these comments?
Report Comment
Eagle 4, Tulsa (4/2/2009 9:55:39 AM)
Why, the Editor of Controversy chooses these letters and articles! He has a blood pressure monitor attached to him and if the gauge does not pass 180 on the systolic the specimen is rejected as "unworthy of print." LOL

Ken, keep your delusions and your smoke rings out of my space, please.
Report Comment
Popeye, T-Town (4/2/2009 12:15:35 PM)
Krispy Kreme Donuts is looking for a shift leader, solving the oral fixation side to quitting; cravings should abate quickly: Quit smoking NOW / Apply Within!
Report Comment
fredsdad, Tulsa, OK (4/2/2009 12:22:13 PM)
Ken, you're fighting a losing battle. I no longer smoke, but did until a couple of years ago. I don't mind if people smoke, but I am very much in the minority.

You could have garnered more support had you written a letter in favor of child abuse.
Report Comment
Proud Muslim, Tulsa: Coolest place in the world (almost) (4/2/2009 1:14:16 PM)
Haha, Eagle, I suspect you're right.

Ken, smoking is unhealthy. It's a fact.
Report Comment
Ignatz, Broken Bow (4/2/2009 1:33:39 PM)
Blowing smoke in your child's face IS child abuse!
Report Comment
Ayo, T-Town (4/2/2009 3:34:45 PM)
I still smoke, but have cut back, and now with the new tax I think it's time to quit. That said, I had a procedure about a year ago, and saw my lungs on x-ray. I could see some damage. Also, even though I'm quite healthy, I can still feel some damage to my respiratory system. If I quit now I think much of that will be repaired over time, but I still may not be able to avoid lung CA.

If you aren't going to quit, at least switch to the brands which are 100% tobacco. There are three brands made by tribes which do not have the chemical additives.

or, only use tobacco for ceremonial purposes.
Report Comment
Howard Beale, (4/2/2009 3:43:23 PM)
Ayo,

I used nicorette gum to kick my nicotine addiction. It made quitting easy.
Report Comment
Howard Beale, (4/2/2009 3:47:25 PM)
I just read the letter to the editor, he must be a liberal democrat to live in that fantasy world.

It reminds me of the Woody Allen movie "Sleeper" where the character played by Allen offers someone waking up in the future a cigarette, saying "Its tobacco, it is good for you".
Report Comment
rockfan, broken arrow (4/2/2009 4:48:45 PM)
Frakes im a smoker and i have to tell that Big Tobbacco gave up that speil along time ago,in the 50s they tried to connect the anti smoking movement to a Communist conspiracy.
They have'nt been called cancer stix for nothin y'know!im trying to quit cause they're bad for my health and now my wallet!so keep puffin there guy i'll see you at the Great Gig in the sky.
Report Comment
Bullhead, Nicut (4/2/2009 8:49:48 PM)
You're stupid, Ken. There, I said it. The problem is, smokers know what they're doing to themselves. It's just that they don't care enough to quit. They obviously have never seen someone smother to death and be fully aware that they are dying and are in full panic mode, begging for someone to help them, scratching and pulling on the arm of their loved one or a nurse or a doctor who can do nothing but stand there and watch the horror in the eyes of the dying.

You're day will come, Mr. Frakes. I'd say, May you die in peace, but that's not going to happen.
 

 
Add Your Comment 
In order to post a comment on this article, you must sign in to Tulsaworld.com. If you do not have a site account, you can create an account for free.

 
  
Post Your Comment
 




Sport Blogs

Mike Strain
Good e-mails: Quarterback issues and Mangino woes

Dave Sittler
What The Heck Was Gundy Thinking?

John Klein
Not Pretty But it Is a Win

The Picker
Team Pansy

Jimmie Tramel
Cheater (the one in the hoodie) doesn't prosper










Tulsa World

Home | About Tulsa World | Advertise With Us | Privacy | Usage Agreement | FAQ and Help | Contact Us | Today's Headlines
Copyright © 2009, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.




Advanced Search