Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on RSS
Sports Extra!
Follow us on ...
OU | OSU | TU | ORU | HIGH SCHOOLS | COLLEGE FOOTBALL | COLLEGE BASKETBALL | NFL | FANTASY | OUTDOORS | GOLF | PROS | ALL




SPORTS EXTRA BLOGS
    Sports Editor
Mike Strain

Sports Columnist
Dave Sittler

The Picker
Entertaining & Infuriating

LOCAL PROS

ALL SPORTS

PHOTOS & VIDEOS

OUTDOORS

FIND A STORY

EMAIL ALERTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

RSS FEEDS

CONTACT US
BUY PHOTOS & PAGES

TULSA WORLD

ADVERTISE ON SPORTS EXTRA



Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

Coaches' votes to be anonymous
Starting in 2010, the final poll results will not be made public

TU coach Todd Graham was the only coach in Oklahoma to vote in the poll last year. MIKE SIMONS/Tulsa World
 
By MIKE STRAIN AND GUERIN EMIG World Sports Writers
Published: 5/28/2009  2:33 AM
Last Modified: 5/28/2009  3:48 AM

College football coaches have high profile jobs, but when it's time to vote on national-championship game combatants, they soon will be anonymous.

Starting in the 2010 season, the final coaches poll will no longer be made public. The poll is one-third of a formula that determines the teams in the BCS championship game.

The American Football Coaches Association announced the decision Wednesday. The AFCA consulted Gallup World Poll to examine the process by which college coaches are polled. Gallup recommended making the poll private, said AFCA executive director Grant Teaff.

Teaff said Gallup made the recommendation because a private ballot produces the most reliable results.

"Why do you think they have voting booths," Teaff said in a telephone interview Wednesday with the Tulsa World. "Why do you think they have curtains around voting booths. Experts believe that's the truest way of getting the purest vote. That's what coaches are after."

The coaches' poll, the Harris poll and computer rankings are each one-third of a formula used to select the two teams that play in the Bowl Championship Series championship game. The final coaches poll has been made public each year since 2005.

Last year, Tulsa's Todd Graham was the only coach in Oklahoma who voted in the top 25 football poll. Graham said he supported the AFCA's decision to make the ballot private, but...

"For me, I liked it being public, because it shows people how you voted," said Graham, who was a top 25 voter for the first time last season.

"... I for one did not have a problem with it being public. The reason why is accountability, so you didn't have something off the wall."

Attempts to contact Oklahoma coach Bob Stoops and Oklahoma State coach Mike Gundy were unsuccessful.

The AFCA waited until the 2010 season to implement anonymity in the coaches poll "to coincide with the current BCS bowl cycle," according to a press release.

The BCS television agreement with Fox expires after this season. From January 2011 to January 2014, ESPN has the TV rights to BCS games.

Graham said he hasn't been contacted yet about voting again this season.

Graham said balancing voting with his full-time job as TU coach wasn't easy, but it was important.

"I think it's very important that you do your research from coast to coast and that you're staying on top of it and that you're very prudent about your vote," Graham said. "I think the coaches poll is very important because of the expertise the coaches have."

The AFCA received multiple recommendations from Gallup. Coaches will continue to be allowed to vote for their own teams, and members of the voting panel will be chosen randomly. Each conference will have half its institutions represented in the voting.

In making its announcement about the football poll, the AFCA didn't specify how many coaches would vote in 2009. Last season, 61 voted. In 2007, there were 60 voters.


Mike Strain, 581-8356, Guerin Emig, 581-8355
mike.strain@tulsaworld.com, guerin.emig@tulsaworld.com
By MIKE STRAIN AND GUERIN EMIG World Sports Writers

Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark


COMMENTS 
      Add your comment Show: Most Recent Comment First

35 comments have been made for this team so far. Tell us what you think below!

Report Comment Reporting Comments

If you see a comment that violates our terms and conditions, please help us by clicking the "Report this Comment" link next to a comment. That will alert the web staff to review the comment. Thank you.  -- Web Editor Jason Collington
 

 
Some reader comments for this story were copied from "College football coaches poll to become anonymous again," which was published on 5/27/2009.

Report Comment
TK1, (5/27/2009 1:41:04 PM)
Does this mean we won't know who Mack Brown voted for? (Of course we will, he'll be that lone UT vote hanging like a chad)
Report Comment
Arbythree, Tulsa (5/27/2009 1:41:33 PM)
Now Mack Brown can hide again.

BOOMER SOONER!!
Report Comment
Ignatz, Broken Bow (5/27/2009 1:59:31 PM)
Sure, Jim, and I plan on retiring on my Nobel Peace Prize cash.
Report Comment
Arbythree, Tulsa (5/27/2009 1:59:42 PM)
Put the paint thinner down Jim.
Report Comment
Bob 1, BA (5/27/2009 2:14:16 PM)
So why don't they just settle it on the field. Play the game and leave the chance of human error out of it.............
Report Comment
Ignatz, Broken Bow (5/27/2009 2:15:35 PM)
Bob 1, indeed.
Report Comment
Arbythree, Tulsa (5/27/2009 2:23:56 PM)
Yes Vern. Bowden has not been the same since we kicked them in their own State for the Championship.

BOOMER SOONER!
Report Comment
concernedpapa, Kiefer (5/27/2009 2:38:02 PM)
nice to see we can come togeather when it really counts
Report Comment
hibeam, (5/27/2009 2:47:52 PM)
Yeah Jim and my IRA is going to come back
Report Comment
hibeam, (5/27/2009 2:48:25 PM)
Yeah Jim and my IRA is going to come back NOT!
Report Comment
Kat Hat, Owasso (5/27/2009 2:59:50 PM)
This is epic fail... EPIC FAIL!
Report Comment
Dad, Up North (5/27/2009 3:13:58 PM)
Jim, quit adding the vodka to the prune juice.
Boomer!
Report Comment
MexiMike, tulsa (5/27/2009 3:32:40 PM)
Jim, I like you stirring the pot. I am an OSU fan and as much as the odds don't favor us winning the national championship, we can now say we are in the mix. Being a team ranked in the pre-season top 10, what's wrong with that? OU fans, try to take off the crimson colored glasses and look at it objectively.

By the way, Howard Schnellenberger said that OU cheated to get every one of their championships when he had just became THE COACH of OU. Maybe that has something to do with the grinding axe?
Report Comment
Kat Hat, Owasso (5/27/2009 3:36:52 PM)
"By the way, Howard Schnellenberger said that OU cheated to get every one of their championships when he had just became THE COACH of OU. Maybe that has something to do with the grinding axe?"

Odds are he'd already had a little too much from the snifter (i.e. - he was breathing) when he made that comment...

However, knowing our well known cheating past, at least I can say that cheating is ANOTHER thing OU is still better at than OSU... After all, how many national championships did Hart Lee bring OSU? Hahahahahaha! :-)
Report Comment
junkman, Tulsa (5/27/2009 3:45:04 PM)
Now Mack Brown can complain some more....who cares ....let's have a playoff
Report Comment
MexiMike, tulsa (5/27/2009 3:47:18 PM)
Kat Hat, your statement is very, very sad.
Report Comment
Arbythree, Tulsa (5/27/2009 4:03:22 PM)
MexiMike, I would say that to "be in the National Championship Mix" a team needs to have more than one decent season.

Osu is a few away from that.
Report Comment
007Dad, (5/27/2009 4:09:30 PM)
Fat Hat...Go check the amount of national championships, in all sports, that OU has won and then check to see how many OSU has won. When you find the answer, then come back and talk crap. I bet you didn't even go to school at OU. Suck on that for a little while.
Report Comment
Arbythree, Tulsa (5/27/2009 4:36:59 PM)
Thanks for the history lesson Shadow. See you in the National Championship Game.

ROFLMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Report Comment
007Dad, (5/27/2009 4:56:32 PM)
Arbythree...you've proven you can't win the big game. Step aside, little sister is big now.
Report Comment
bruinsooner, (5/27/2009 4:57:51 PM)
ShadowKnows: Thanks for the history lesson. I guess all Sooner fans are land thieves? By the way, didn't the cowboys kill a bunch of Indians? No offense to Native Americans only to ShadowKnows.
Report Comment
Scritchner, Tulsa (5/27/2009 5:29:49 PM)
I heard Urban Meyer is coming out with a rap CD called "Ballz Deep in Tebow"
Report Comment
wk, (5/27/2009 7:45:29 PM)
Jim - Haven't spent much time following OSU football have you my friend?
Report Comment
a disciple, Glenpool (5/28/2009 5:54:02 AM)
The association needs to reconsider this decision. Without public knowledge and accountability, the coaches will be suspected of fraud and possibly bribery. Making the votes public ensures more integrity in the process. I have a feeling that this rule will be overturned before it takes effect.
Report Comment
MexiMike, tulsa (5/28/2009 9:19:00 AM)
Roastbeef, you are absolutely wrong. I'll use OU as an example.

In the '99 season, OU went to which bowl? Ahh yes, the very prestigious Independence Bowl (in which they lost).

What happened the very next year? A national championship.

This had nothing to do with OU's illustrious history decades before. It had everything to do with the coaches and players jelling at the right time. There was nothing that OU did in the '99 season that led anyone to believe they would be National Champs the next year. Yet, they got there and won.

With that being said, OSU being ranked in the Top 10 pre-season, returning all their firepower on offense, and having a well proven D-coordinator shaping up the defense definitely puts them right in the mix.
25 of 35 comments displayed. | View All

 

 
Add Your Comment 
In order to post a comment on this article, you must sign in to Tulsaworld.com. If you do not have a site account, you can create an account for free.

 
Post Your Comment
 



Home | About Tulsa World | Advertise With Us | Privacy | Usage Agreement | FAQ and Help | Contact Us | Today's Headlines
Copyright © 2010, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.