Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Twitter Follow us on RSS
Sports Extra!
Follow us on ...
OU | OSU | TU | ORU | HIGH SCHOOLS | COLLEGE FOOTBALL | COLLEGE BASKETBALL | NFL | FANTASY | OUTDOORS | GOLF | PROS | ALL




SPORTS EXTRA BLOGS
    Sports Editor
Mike Strain

Sports Columnist
Dave Sittler

The Picker
Entertaining & Infuriating

LOCAL PROS

ALL SPORTS

PHOTOS & VIDEOS

OUTDOORS

FIND A STORY

EMAIL ALERTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

RSS FEEDS

CONTACT US
BUY PHOTOS & PAGES

TULSA WORLD

ADVERTISE ON SPORTS EXTRA



Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark

Are issues widespread?
OSSAA leader says Jenks, BTW cases are isolated incidents.

Suspended Jenks coach Allan Trimble CORY YOUNG/Tulsa World

 
By MATT BAKER World Sports Writer
Published: 10/29/2009  2:31 AM
Last Modified: 10/29/2009  5:52 AM


Related story: More trouble awaits BTW?

Two of Oklahoma's top high school football programs — Jenks and Booker T. Washington — have doled out self-imposed penalties for multiple rules violations this month. Both investigations revealed allegations of recruiting and resulted in the suspensions of head coaches and athletic directors.

In light of eligibility issues for two teams that have been ranked No. 1 in the state this season, do Oklahoma high schools have a serious problem with rules violations?

"I think they're isolated," said Ed Sheakley, executive director for the Oklahoma Secondary School Activities Association. "We've gone through years and years and not had any violations of this mass, of this type, that we're aware of."

The OSSAA looks into every tip it receives on recruiting or the use of possibly ineligible students. Sheakley said the OSSAA includes 484 high schools, and only a handful have been guilty of major violations.

But the latest two instances have been high-profile.

At Booker T. Washington, two sets of recruiting violations took place, according to a report released by Tulsa Public Schools on Tuesday. One involved assistant football coach Scott Gilkey driving two student-athletes — his daughter and a longtime family friend — 90 miles round-trip to the school.

Another student played in the spring football game but was not enrolled in the district, which is also a violation of OSSAA rules. The Hornets forfeited two games this season, jeopardizing their chances of defending the Class 5A state championship.

Jenks was runner-up in Class 6A last season, but had to forfeit nine wins for using an ineligible player, Jarrett Lake. Following an investigation by a Tulsa law firm which revealed problems with seven students dating back to 1998, the OSSAA indefinitely suspended Jenks head coach Allan Trimble and assistant coach David Alexander.

This season, Jenks is undefeated and ranked No. 1.

Stephanie Spring, TPS' athletic director, said she thinks eligibility issues surrounding two football powerhouses will force other schools to be more careful with the rules.

"After what happened at two storied programs like Jenks and Booker T., I believe schools are going to be paying more attention to the rules than ever before, and that they will be more diligent and proactive to make sure they are not violating any rules," said Spring, who is also the president of the OSSAA's board of directors.

Many problems arise simply because of the sheer load of paperwork involved, said Terry Simpson, the board's vice president and the superintendent at Guthrie Public Schools. When students transfer without making a bona fide move into a district, four different OSSAA forms should be filled out.

Sometimes, athletic directors or principals overlook forms. Washington didn't have the proper documentation on at least three student-athletes, according to the school's investigation.

"Unfortunately, we're in a situation where we are at schools inundated with forms and paperwork," said Simpson, who was speaking generally and not addressing the specific cases of Jenks or Washington. "Do I think it's getting lost in the shuffle? Yeah, I do, sometimes.

"As often as not, we have ineligible students due to a lack of knowledge that they're ineligible."

A top program also breeds high expectations from players and parents, said Milt Bassett, the executive director of the Oklahoma Coaches Association. When a team competes for a state championship regularly, the community expects winning to become a tradition.

"You would hope that our coaches in Oklahoma would have enough pride to want to play by the rules and not be pressured into winning at all costs," Bassett said. "When you build a monster like that, you've got to keep feeding it, it seems like. You hope your coaches have enough integrity to play by the rules and do it the right way."

OSSAA board member Bob Bush said a handful of schools will always try to bend the rules in order to win, but he believes most coaches compete honestly. Bush, the superintendent of Seiling Schools, said the OSSAA's rules are sound, and every required form is there for a reason.

He said he hopes problems at Jenks and Booker T. Washington get other schools to look carefully at their compliance and report violations.

"I see this as a wake-up call for everybody," Bush said. "I can't help but believe that because of that, this has come to the forefront, and there will probably be some others. But as far as this being a major epidemic, I don't think so."


Matt Baker 581-8358
matt.baker@tulsaworld.com
By MATT BAKER World Sports Writer

Newspaper View Newspaper View      Print this story Print      Email this story Email     
Share      Bookmark Bookmark


COMMENTS 
      Add your comment Show: Most Recent Comment First

41 comments have been made for this team so far. Tell us what you think below!

Report Comment Reporting Comments

If you see a comment that violates our terms and conditions, please help us by clicking the "Report this Comment" link next to a comment. That will alert the web staff to review the comment. Thank you.  -- Web Editor Jason Collington
 

 
Report Comment
AJMcV, (10/29/2009 6:05:48 AM)
Not a suprise, Coach Jimmerson was trained by Jenks Head Football Coach Trimble. (Jimmerson was one of Trimble's assistant football coachs at Jenks, before going to Tulsa)
Report Comment
Teddy Bear 1975, Eufaula (10/29/2009 6:45:14 AM)
CASICA HALL is going down next. They are violating rules. Just keep tune it wiil happen.
Report Comment
Cougarkitty, (10/29/2009 6:57:26 AM)
Teddy Bear either speak up and give details or shut the hell up....
Report Comment
okhoopster1, (10/29/2009 7:44:08 AM)
OSSAA claims these are isolated? How would they know....unless they already knew. hmmmmm?
Report Comment
okhoopster1, (10/29/2009 7:44:37 AM)
BEGGS HS NEXT!
Report Comment
dignified, Tulsa (10/29/2009 8:40:44 AM)
Isn't it pathetic, two supposed "power houses" and they are both cheaters!!!!

Good grief, what were these coaches thinking???

Must make the schools, TPS, and the state of OKlahoma proud!!!
Report Comment
T.B'Ville, Bruins (10/29/2009 9:07:58 AM)
The OSSAA better make examples of all the coaches and principles that had a hand in this. They better fire them and ban them for life or this WILL NOT be taken serious.
Report Comment
getreal, (10/29/2009 9:24:03 AM)
Cascia Hall may be in violation. They require their athletes to go to class, make their grades, etc. In Oklahoma, this is certainly a violation of football rules.

Being serious, if you think they are cheating, stop just saying it and call the OSSAA and prove it.
Report Comment
DomoArrigato, Outside of Tulsa (10/29/2009 9:34:16 AM)
"I think they're isolated," said Ed Sheakley, executive director for the Oklahoma Secondary School Activities Association. "We've gone through years and years and not had any violations of this mass, of this type, that we're aware of."

If you don't bother to check, and let the coachs "report" problems, I guess that you wouldn't be aware of them
Report Comment
pogo, Pryor (10/29/2009 9:47:21 AM)
The OSSAA says they're not aware of "any violations of this mass." Remember, this is the same group that had someone steal nearly $500,000 from them before it was discovered. I know of several students who "school shop." They go from school to school depending on the success of a school hoping to play on a championship team. I heard one parent say her football player son had been to three different schools, but the parents had never moved. I also know of schools who've asked students to come play for them. The OSSAA has buried their heads in the sand. They don't want to know.
Report Comment
jomatt, (10/29/2009 10:08:25 AM)
Isolated?! HAHAHAHAHA!
Report Comment
GoFigure, (10/29/2009 10:13:21 AM)
Who polices this OSSAA? How could you have someone there steal 500,000 before you discovered it, and still hope to govern athletics effectively across this whole state. Seems like in years past they could care less about who's committed infractions and now all of a sudden this gumshoe gets caught stealing all this money and "now" all of a sudden, they've decided to enforce the so-called rules, which most of these schools don't even know what they are because this weak organization fails to supply them proper procedures to follow. All of this sounds like the new guy in charge is wanting a feather in his cap. Sounds like the whole bunch of them should have been fired and that whole organization rebuilt with qualified people. Why do we let this kind of crap go on in this state.
Report Comment
Makeda, Tulsa (10/29/2009 10:31:17 AM)
GoFigure: You are so right! But this is Tulsa and TPS, so everyone does what they want to do till they get caught. Who is going to make changes at OSSAA? Stephanie needs to go and so does most of the staff. They won't do anything but wait for people to ask them to do their job, so I am contacting them today to say, go down the line and check all of your schools...what else do they have to do. If the two powerhouse schools are doing it, you better believe others are following their footsteps!
Report Comment
d van, Tulsa (10/29/2009 10:40:57 AM)
My question is:
Is the BTW backup QB ruled ineligible for this season as a punitive measure because of last school year's inclusion in spring events?

Since they're separate school years, The team is being punished this year for last school year's infractions.

The OSSAA says they punish the school in the school year that the infraction occured, but that's not how they treat athletes. Albert is being punished this year for what he did last school year.(even though he's specificly ruled as eligible since Oct. 9th)

Perhaps the OSSAA considers spring practices as de-facto segments of the next school year's sporting season?

But I don't see how Albert is forced to quit this season?
Report Comment
Steff M, Claremore (10/29/2009 11:05:15 AM)
Specificly? Apparently he was ruled eligible before they knew about his participation last spring. Obviously they can't go back in time and punish last years team which was already finished with their season when the infraction occurred.
Report Comment
GoFigure, (10/29/2009 11:10:46 AM)
d van, You've got to remember, the OSSAA doesn't know what it's doing. How does a kid at Jenks miss a whole years' eligibility for 09' when his infraction occurred in 08'. He's properly enrolled for 09'and hasn't committed infractions for 09' but is sitting out the whole year because this OSSAA says so! They don't know what they're doing and thats' been evident for years. They make up this crap as they go and investigate whoever they think will get them the most press releases it seems.
Report Comment
tulsa coach, tulsa (10/29/2009 11:12:10 AM)
Trust me... Every school is doing something wrong. It is just "who will get caught".
What are we setting up our kids for???
Will they cheat in college?? I think it's all they know...
Report Comment
d van, Tulsa (10/29/2009 11:15:10 AM)
The entire OSSAA structure is obsolete and inept.

Schools ought to start an alternative organization.

Holland Hall is starting to look like geniuses for opting out and joining a Texas Conference.
Report Comment
dcood, (10/29/2009 11:21:00 AM)
Now you are gettin the idea. I love Sheakley's response:'there have not been major violations like this before... as far as we know.' They didnt even realize their boss was stealing almost half a million in cash.
Report Comment
zack, pryor (10/29/2009 11:28:42 AM)
Make it easy if you change schools from inside the state for any reason you must sit out one year if you come from out of state then you fill out the paperwork it will decreasethe sheer load as reported.That puts the spot light back on academics. That seems to be what everyone says is why they move.
Report Comment
d van, Tulsa (10/29/2009 11:35:27 AM)
The OSSAA either get a Guestaupo policing force or rewrite the written rules. Right now they are caught looking like Sargeant Shultz, and acting like Jeckyl & Hyde.

The rules are tough enough but the system for policing is very enept. They let the "foxes run the henhouse".

They leave it up to schools to investigate their own crimes!(Can you say "cover up"?)

How can boosters really be sufficiently policed?

The AD gets paid by the school board but must make account to the OSSAA.

The OSSAA can't punish the ADs, but they take it out on the Head Coaches.

The Head Coaches are ordered by principals to submit to the ADs and let the ADs do the policing and reporting.
Report Comment
Karma, (10/29/2009 11:57:32 AM)
Blatant cheating does NOT go on everywhere, at every school, it just doesn't. Now, are there legitimate mistakes made, yes probably quiet a bit. This stuff has gone on for years with some of these schools, I do not know about BTW, but we all it has happened at Jenks and Union for a number of years, while the OSSAA sat by and did nothing about it, the OSSAA is a joke, why would Danny Rennels want to pursue a school for cheating, when he is bilking the OSSAA out of $500,000, it is the old saying, "don't throw stones if you live in a glass house." I think the only reason they pursued these two cases, is because they were almost forced to, it is not that they wanted to. I heard Union may get turned in for a kid living in another town, and riding to school with an assistant football coach in the fall of 2004, that coach now coaches at another large Tulsa Metro school, wonder if he will be suspended too?
Report Comment
JayZOne, (10/29/2009 12:27:07 PM)
I hope the OSSAA continues to also evaluate the private schools. It is not a coincidence that the #1 rated schools in 2A, 3A, and 5A are private. They should have to compete at least one, if not two classes higher than their enrollment dictates.
Report Comment
d van, Tulsa (10/29/2009 12:52:00 PM)
JayZ,
What logical argument do you have for mandating private schools play non-privates that are 9 times thier size?

Bishop McGuinness (686 students) would play Broken Arrow (4461 students).

Claremore Christian has 40 kids. you'd make them compete with Hominy (198).

You sound like a whiner, unless you have a logical argument for such a penalty.

And saying that "we keep losing" doen't count as a reason for penalizing the winners.

Govt. bureacracy leads to a lack of efficiency. That's what leads to these results.

A student's "G.I. bill" would fix the problem by making the govt. schools get more competitive. Let the govt. money follow the student.

Charter schools are just govt' schools with a reprieve from some of the bureaucracy.
Report Comment
hawkdaddy, (10/29/2009 1:10:14 PM)
These problems do exist in many places and have less to do with intended malice but more to do with the schools inability to track them. Most schools do not intentionally cheat but lack the resources to investigate such issues.

There may be more schools caught but it's up to disgruntled parents to turn them in because the OSSAA is certainly not going to investigate. You can look at all the major players in high school football and you are likely to find some problems if you dig deep enough. Kids and Parents look at the championship trophies and incredible facilities at some of these schools and want to be part of it, sometimes at any cost.

Hopefully the current hub bub about all of this will encourage everyone to clean house.
25 of 41 comments displayed. | View All

 

 
Add Your Comment 
In order to post a comment on this article, you must sign in to Tulsaworld.com. If you do not have a site account, you can create an account for free.

 
Post Your Comment
 



Home | About Tulsa World | Advertise With Us | Privacy | Usage Agreement | FAQ and Help | Contact Us | Today's Headlines
Copyright © 2010, World Publishing Co. All rights reserved.